Clinical negligence: defendant in North West

Clyde & Co

Clyde & Co houses a broad practice known for handling fatal accident inquiries, inquests, and criminal proceedings. Claire Petts (who divides her time between Manchester and London) co-leads the team alongside ‘absolute dynamo’ Vanessa Splaine and Sarah Woodwark. Splaine’s primary areas of expertise include brain and spinal injury cases in both newborns and adults, with a successful record in settling claims by way of periodical payment orders. Woodwark often handles cases concerning cosmetic surgery, oral cancer, and dental procedures. Rachel Barnes is particularly adept at handling clinical claims against nurses, and laser eye surgery cases. Louise Jackson, noted for her work for the Medical Protection Society, is ‘tireless, highly intelligent and meticulous‘ in her representation of private clinicians and primary care practitioners.

Responsables de la pratique:

Claire Petts; Vanessa Splaine; Sarah Woodwark


Autres avocats clés:

Deborah Boyd; Andrea Crisp; Rachel Barnes; Christina Bateman; Louise Jackson; Bethan Parry; Matthew Tippin


Les références

‘Efficient, professional and focused. Communications were always flawless and responses substantive and constructive.’

‘Louise Jackson handled my case. She is tireless, highly intelligent and meticulous in her dissection of the facts and events and brought a new level of in depth probing and analysis to the claim. She was proactive and thoughtful and revisited many aspects with a renewed vigour and was always approachable and helpful with her questions.’

‘Everyone I have worked with within this team has been engaged with their cases, abreast of the detail and enthusiastic to get a good outcome. They are responsive and always take a pragmatic, considered view.’

Principaux clients

Berkshire Hathaway International Insurance Ltd


Medical Protection Society


Dental Protection


RSA


Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust


NHS Resolution


MDDUS


Premium Medical Protection


Zurich


Chubb


Hillingdon Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


DAC Beachcroft LLP

DAC Beachcroft LLP houses a ‘vastly experienced’ team in Manchester, known for handling GP indemnity issues, claims concerning mental health services, and product liability and clinical negligence matters relating to medical devices. Team lead Simon Wortley assists a diverse client list of independent healthcare providers, insurers, and hospitals with a variety of issues including methods of consent. Sean Doherty, who is praised by clients for being ‘proactive and knowledgeable‘, is particularly adept at wrongful birth claims, and group actions against the NHS concerning the actions of orthopaedic surgeons. The ‘very clever and thorough’ Claire Fitzgerald regularly acts for UK insurers in overseas claims.

Responsables de la pratique:

Simon Wortley


Autres avocats clés:

Sean Doherty, Claire Fitzgerald; Bridie Mahoney


Les références

‘An absolute leader in this field. Sean Doherty is outstanding.’

‘Industry sector knowledge and expertise is exceptional, and personal skills further serve to differentiate DACB.’

‘A strong team, these are are one of the big players, with an excellent caseload and high quality running throughout the team.’

Principaux clients

Circle Health Group


HCA International Ltd


Medical Defence Union


Dental Defence Union


Schoen Clinic UK


Teladoc Health UK


Elysium Healthcare Ltd


NHS Resolution


Florence Nightingale Hospital


Insurance Corporation of the Channel Islands


Newline Group


MS Amlin


Allied World Assurance Company


Zurich


Beazley


Royal Sun Alliance


CNA Hardy


Evodental


Marsh McLennan


AMMA Assurance (Belgium)


Medical Professional Liability Co. (MPLC)


Watson Tower Wilson


Intereurope AG


Aon UK


Manchester University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust


Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


NHS England/Improvement


Hull University Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust


Barnsley Hospital NHS Foundation Trust


Liverpool University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust


Harrogate & District NHS Foundation Trust


Doncaster & Bassetlaw Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


NOE CPC


NHS SBS


Blackpool Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Luke Cascarini Ltd


Simply Loyal Ltd


Principaux dossiers


  • Assisted the MDU and its Members, including GPs, practice nurses, surgery and anaesthetics with cauda equina spinal claims and neurological injuries.
  • Assisting NHS Resolution with GP indemnity work under the clinical negligence scheme for general practice and under the existing liabilities scheme for general practice.

Hill Dickinson LLP

The Liverpool-based group at Hill Dickinson LLP handles the full spectrum of clinical negligence mandates, with notable clients including NHS Resolution, Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust, and CNA Hardy. Andrew Craggs acts as the group’s national team lead, alongside David Locke. Craggs is well-known for his vast expertise in claims involving sexual assault and bullying, while Locke handles a wide variety of cases related to gender reassignment, neonatal death, and collective claims against NHS bodies. Joanne Hughes has deep knowledge of GP claims, and the ‘wonderfulNick Citron‘s caseload primarily consists of brain and spinal injuries, and amputations. Claire Christopholus assists NHS trusts and Integrated Care Boards (ICB) with mandates involving mental capacity and deprivation of liberty safeguards.

Responsables de la pratique:

Andrew Craggs; David Locke


Autres avocats clés:

Nick Citron; Joanne Hughes; Claire Christopholus; Jonathan Heap


Les références

‘Nick Citron is wonderful. Always exceptionally well prepared and has a wonderful rapport with clients.’

‘Hill Dickinson’s clinical negligence team has provided us with top class specialist assistance that consistently exceeds expectation. A friendly, knowledgeable and efficient team that is always on hand, and has time for a talk-through if needed.’

‘David Locke – hugely experienced. Very efficient – quick to assess strengths and weaknesses of a case. A good man to have in your corner – gets straight to the heart of a claim and provides firm clear advice.’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


CNA Hardy


Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust


Shrewsbury & Telford Hospital NHS Trust


Principaux dossiers


  • Advising an NHS trust on the associated civil claims following the criminal conviction of a neonatal nurse for multiple murders and attempted murders.
  • Representing an NHS trust in a group action against the NHS resulting from a data breach.
  • Advising the NHS Commissioning Board on a matter which concerns the decommissioning and recommissioning from another supplier(s) of services relating to gender reassignment treatment.

Weightmans LLP

Working out of the Liverpool office, Weightmans LLP routinely acts in public inquiries and large-scale group actions. Regularly acting for private healthcare providers and NHS trusts, co-head Richard Jolly has extensive knowledge of birth injury cases, while Vicky Morris routinely advises clients on patient safety incidents and group actions. Ian Critchley is noted for his longstanding experience in spinal injury and delayed diagnosis cases. In Manchester, Lisa Spencer is particularly adept at handling claims concerning foetal exposure to sodium valproate, and Chris Dexter is an expert in claims brought by clients under the NHS Resolution General Practice indemnity schemes and dental negligence cases. Samuel Harland is an expert in blood borne infections and chemical exposure, often engaging in alternative dispute resolution methods.

Responsables de la pratique:

Richard Jolly; Ian Critchley; Vicky Morris


Autres avocats clés:

Chris Dexter; Lisa Spencer; Alison Brennan; Samuel Harland; Chloe Parker


Les références

‘Excellent commitment and skills. Great to work with and always available when needed.’

‘Vicky Morris is excellent; incredibly well committed. Gives everything to the job and provides a stellar service.’

‘Senior partners are excellent. Top quality representation in complex cases.’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


IDH


Markel


Lancashire Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust


Wrightington, Wigan & Leigh NHS Foundation Trust


Tameside & Glossop Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust


Wirral University Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust


Chesterfield Royal Hospital NHS Foundation Trust


NHS Blood & Transplant


Wirral Community NHS FT


Principaux dossiers


  • Advising NHS Resolution, NHS Blood and Transplant, the Department of Health and various NHS Trusts in relation to several proposed group actions being brought by and on behalf of people infected with viruses, including HIV, hepatitis C and hepatitis B through the use of blood and blood products.
  • Instructed by NHS Resolution to advise NHS Trusts in relation to claims involving foetal exposure to sodium valproate.
  • Instructed by the St Helena Government to set up and run a compensation scheme for any patients who suffered avoidable harm during treatment by a doctor employed on the British Overseas Territory.

Browne Jacobson LLP

Leveraging its national network, Browne Jacobson LLP acts for a varied client base which notably includes the Medical Protection Society, Dental Protection Limited, and Blackpool Teaching Hospitals. Clinical negligence litigator Amanda Callaghan heads up the Manchester team, and Rachael Mounsey has broad expertise in high-value obstetric claims, in addition to deep knowledge of public law. Nigel Wood and Carena Fullerton joined the group from Hempsons and DAC Beachcroft LLP respectively in December 2023. Wood often acts for medical defence organisations and NHS trusts, with a strong focus on elective ophthalmic treatments, while Fullerton is known for her broad expertise in claims involving serious brain injury and orthopaedic surgery.

Responsables de la pratique:

Amanda Callaghan


Autres avocats clés:

Rachael Mounsey; Carena Fullerton; Nigel Wood


Les références

‘Nigel Wood is a massive addition to the team. He is a titan in the Manchester clinical negligence community.’

‘Carena Fullerton is an excellent recent addition to the Healthcare Team. She is commercially focused and a pleasure to deal with.’

‘Nigel Wood gives good succinct advice.’

Principaux clients

Medical Protection Society


NHS Resolution


Dental Protection Limited


Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust


Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust


CNA Hardy


Blackpool Teaching Hospitals


University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust


Essex Partnership University NHS Trust


University Hospital of Dorset NHS Foundation Trust