Carson McDowell‘s healthcare claims and defence insurance litigation team is known for its robust defence-side clinical negligence practice and its strengths in personal injury claims, covering employers’ liability, public liability and product liability. Roger McMillan and Jacqueline McAleese co-lead the clinical negligence defence department. McMillan is a go-to for medical defence organisations and is an expert in neurology-related claims, while ‘excellent’ litigator McAleese focuses on defending birth and brain injury cases. Catherine Carton and Cathal O’Neill head up the insurance personal injury team. Carton has a broad workload, from bullying and harassment in the workplace to industrial disease claims. O’Neill is experienced in handling significant asbestos claims.
Personal injury and clinical negligence: defendant in Northern Ireland
Carson McDowell
Responsables de la pratique:
Roger McMillan; Jacqueline McAleese; Cathal O’Neill; Catherine Carton
Les références
‘Catherine Carton and Cathal O’Neill provide an exceptional service, and are always available and approachable.’
‘Excellent quality solicitors, very well-organised and resourced.’
‘Cathal O’Neill and Catherine Carton are both brilliant solicitors; hard-working and very sensible – never trying to reinvent the wheel where it’s not necessary.’
Principaux clients
The Medical Protection Society
Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland
Dental Protection
National Pharmaceutical Association
Association of Optometrists
Medical Defence Union
Beazley Group
WRB Underwriting
Personal Injury – Defendant
Great Lakes SE
AIA Australia
Belfast Harbour Commissioners
Kelly Adjusters
Travelers Insurance
Axis Capital
Enstar
Sedgwick
Faraday Insurance
Riverstone Insurance
Davies Casualty/Garwyn
TT Club/Thomas Miller Claims Management
Crawford Loss Adjustors/Broadspire
Northern Ireland Electricity Networks Ltd
Beale & Co
McLarens
Stena Line
QBE
Clyde & Co LLP
The Clyde & Co Belfast team is a go-to for insured clients and insurers, regularly advising on claims related to workplace and road traffic injuries. Cormac Fitzpatrick heads the catastrophic injury and large loss services and is a skilled defence litigator. Graeme Moore is routinely instructed on personal injury claims, while Michelle McCullough is a key point of contact for the firm’s clientele of local major insurers. Naomi Campbell is another name of note.
Responsables de la pratique:
Cormac Fitzpatrick
Autres avocats clés:
Graeme Moore; Michelle McCullough; Naomi Campbell
Principaux dossiers
- Advised on an accident at work in which the Plaintiff employee suffered a fractured pelvis and spinal injuries; the matter resolved at an agreed sum of £750K plus CRU and health service charges totalling just over £70K.
- Representing a Defendant, motorist, who was asked to attend a PACE interview with a view to prosecution for dangerous driving, causing GBH, following a road traffic collision between the motorcyclist and a car in October 2018; the matter ultimately settled immediately prior to Trial in the sum of £875,000 plus High Court costs to be taxed in default of agreement.
- Advised on an accident at work whereby the Plaintiff trapped his right foot in a void when loading pallets, suffering a dislocation injury which severely damaged the peroneal tendon; the case ultimately settled on the day before trial in the sum of £1.75m plus costs to be taxed in default of agreement.
DAC Beachcroft
DAC Beachcroft has a diverse client roster, servicing all types of insurers, from multi-line and specialist line to corporate and clinical negligence insurers. Sean McGahan specialises in higher value personal injury claims, including asbestos litigation and noise-induced hearing loss. Aisling Mellon leads the motor injury team and focuses on motor-related personal injury claims. Louise Butler leads on casualty injury matters, while Catriona McCorry is the go-to for high-value clinical negligence High Court claims. Michael McLarnon‘s caseload consists of credit hire motor claims. Amanda McClimond is highlighted for insurance panel clinical negligence matters.
Responsables de la pratique:
Sean McGahan
Autres avocats clés:
Aisling Mellon; Louise Butler; Catriona McCorry; Michael McLarnon; Amanda McClimond
Les références
‘A well-regarded team that adopts a pragmatic approach to claims handling.’
‘I have worked closely with Amanda McClimmond and find her to be a great defendant solicitor. Amanda is very knowledgeable and reasonable in her approach.’
‘Very strong team, led by excellent partners and ably assisted by high-quality associates, solicitors, and paralegals. Broad variety of work, all dealt with very capably.’
Principaux clients
AIG
Royal and Sun Alliance
Northern Ireland Water Limited
Sabre Insurance Company Limited
Admiral Insurance
Riverstone International
Resolute Management Ltd
Med Pro
Corvelia
HDI Global SE
Principaux dossiers
- Secured evidence proving another party was responsible when NI Water Ltd faced a £1.5 million public liability claim through early investigations.
- Secured a £15,000 settlement in a high-value injury claim for a Corporate insurer, leveraging key evidence and market reputation as a straight dealer.
- Secured our client’s release from a clinical negligence claim involving the implantation of a medical device on the instruction of Beazleys.
Kennedys
Kennedys‘ defence liability and healthcare team has strong expertise in defending medical negligence claims, acting for chiropractors, eye specialists, and private hospitals. The team is proficient in motor claims and occupational disease claims. Practice head Amanda Wylie is a ‘leader’ in defence personal injury litigation, acting in matters related to catastrophic and life-changing injuries. Wylie is regularly supported by ‘excellent performer’ Megan Boyd on instructions for independent health service providers.
Responsables de la pratique:
Amanda Wylie
Autres avocats clés:
Megan Boyd; Ian Martindale; Gareth McKee
Les références
‘A high level of efficiency, knowledge of the areas in question, and good judgement.’
‘The standout partner is Amanda Wylie.’
‘Excellent team – close-knit and provides an excellent service to their insurance clients.’
Tughans
The Tughans insurance and disputes team is singled out for its strength in litigious matters, covering catastrophic personal injury and occupational disease. Head of insurance, Kathy McGillie, is a go-to for the firm’s insurer clientele, and has extensive experience in health and safety regulatory investigations. Alistair Wilson was appointed to head of clinical negligence in 2024, and leads on the full gamut of healthcare mandates for both insured and uninsured doctors and dentists. Neil Smyth is noted for public liability claims, including those from accidents abroad, while litigator Kevin Hegarty is described as a ‘stand-out’ and regularly acts for healthcare providers and medical defence organisations. Other individuals of note include Francesca Glynn and Pauline Walker.
Responsables de la pratique:
Kathy McGillie; Alistair Wilson
Autres avocats clés:
Neil Smyth; Kevin Hegarty; Francesca Glynn; Pauline Walker
Les références
‘The team is by some distance one of the leading lights in insurance defence work generally and particularly in clinical negligence. The team has a long history of doing this work and is highly regarded by colleagues, opponents and the Courts for the work they do. There is a strength in depth with very experienced partners supported by fee earners of varying levels of experience, all of whom provide an excellent service to their clients. ’
‘Alistair is a highly regarded director of the practice who is consistently sought out in clinical negligence work; he has been involved in some of the most interesting work in this jurisdiction on the defence side of clinical negligence cases. I have a lot of experience of Francesca Glynn as I used to work with her and in my experience, she is easily one of the most capable, diligent and knowledgeable solicitors I have dealt with. She is a star in the making and I fully expect she will reach the very top of the profession; she is a dream to work with. ’
‘Generally, I deal with two individuals: Neil Smyth and Pauline Walker. They are very professional and knowledgeable in subject matters and great communicators with all parties involved – very pleased with the quality of work they provide. ’
DWF
The healthcare and insurance team at DWF handles health and safety and regulatory prosecutions for both public and private sector clients, encompassing fatalities and serious injuries. The Belfast team draws on its broader network across the UK, including London, Edinburgh, and Newcastle. Laura Menary and Mark Johnston jointly lead the team. Menary is a highly praised litigator who is instructed by major medical defence organisations and global insurers.
Responsables de la pratique:
Mark Johnston; Laura Menary
Les références
‘The solicitors are well-prepared and resourced, knowledgeable, and commercially astute.’
‘DWF has a very strong and well-regarded insurance defence practice in Belfast and has a broad range of experience and depth of ability across its litigation department.’
‘Laura Menary – a highly experienced solicitor who deals with cases in an efficient and pragmatic manner.’
Principaux clients
Allianz
Axa
Aviva
RSA
QBE
Riverstone
Hiscox
Gallagher Bassett
Covea
LV=
Amlin
NFU Mutual
British Telecoms Plc
Ageas
Liberty
DLG
Amazon
Markerstudy
Enterprise Rentacar
XS Direct
Canopius
Sedgwick
Hastings
Admiral
Travelers
Medical Protection Society
Dental Protection
NHS Resolution
Argo Group
Optical Express
Keoghs LLP
A growing team, Keoghs LLP‘s insurance team advises insurers on a wide breadth of contentious matters, covering road traffic and catastrophic injuries as well as product liability claims. Practice head Victoria McLean is lauded for being a ‘second to none’ defence expert and routinely represents clients in the High Court, particularly for motor accidents. Megan McBrien was appointed partner in 2024 and is noted for representing employers. Rachel Keenan‘s workload consists of motor, employer, and public liability claims.
Responsables de la pratique:
Victoria McLean
Autres avocats clés:
Megan McBrien; Rachel Keenan; Charlene McSparron
Les références
‘Keoghs is a market-leading firm in the Northern Irish jurisdiction. They have superb partners and solicitors, are exceptionally well resourced and marry a commercial client-driven approach to insurance litigation with a fierce determination to obtain the best outcome from any litigation.’
‘Victoria McLean is undoubtedly at the top of the litigation field in this jurisdiction. She is exceptionally well-respected and has vast market experience in complex and high-value litigation. Her preparation and client focus is second to none, and she is a determined advocate in defence of her client’s interests whilst always maintaining a high degree of commerciality.’
‘The litigation team at Keoghs, led by Victoria McLean and Rachel Keenan, is a leading Northern Ireland defence personal injury practice. Their work is of a consistently high standard, forensic, measured and fair. ’
Arthur Cox Belfast
The dispute resolution team at Arthur Cox Belfast represents insurers on a range of personal injury cases, including employers’ liability claims, for which the team is particularly experienced in noise-induced hearing loss matters. Chris Ritchie heads up the team. Ritchie is well-versed in product liability claims.
Responsables de la pratique:
Chris Ritchie
Les références
‘I work with Chris Ritchie. He is very knowledgeable and user-friendly.’
‘Very pleased with the advice and service provided by Chris and his team.’
Principaux clients
Rapid Granulator AB
Northern Ireland Housing Executive
Tetratech
Courtaulds Textiles
UIA Insurance
ZimmerBiomet
Travelers Insurance
Education Authority of NI
Medtonic
Crossbow Optical