Leading Silks

Peter Gray KC – Compass Chambers 'Peter is a consummate professional. He puts clients at their ease even in the most challenging of circumstances, and brings a sense of calm assurance to everything he does. He prepares meticulously for court appearances and he combines gravitas and the ear of the court whenever he appears.'
Duncan Hamilton KC – Arnot Manderson Advocates 'Duncan has an excellent eye for detail, with an exceptional ability to read and absorb large volumes of disclosure material. He excels at identifying the issues of most relevance to the client and developing appropriate strategies.'
Fred Mackintosh KC – Terra Firma Chambers 'A silk who demonstrates meticulous professionalism.'
Murdo MacLeod KC – Compass Chambers 'Murdo has a lot of poise. He knows how to present the evidence for a judge or jury to achieve the best outcome.'
Barry Smith KC – Compass Chambers 'Barry is a fountain of knowledge with regards to the Health and Safety and FAI specialist areas of practice.'
Gavin Anderson KC – Compass Chambers 'An illustrious silk.'
Simon Bowie KC - Ampersand Advocates 'Simon is an exceptional KC. His ability to gather together the key information from large quantities of papers is brilliant.'
Una Doherty KC - Ampersand Advocates 'Her advocacy style is understated yet powerful due to her thoroughness and cogent reasoning.'
Angela Grahame KC - Compass Chambers 'Angela is an excellent silk, with a wealth of experience in public inquiries.'
Lisa Henderson KC - Ampersand Advocates 'Lisa is able to absorb voluminous material covering a variety of complex issues in tight timescales. She is an expert at analysing the detail and pulling out the key points in a case. This strength together with her legal knowledge, drafting skills and advocacy gives clients confidence that they are in safe hands.'
Mark Stewart KC – Compass Chambers 'Mark is an exceptional advocate. His court manner and ability is second to none. He provides advice in a smooth and effortless manner that is always warmly received by clients.'

2023 Silks

Paul Reid KC - Ampersand Advocates 'Paul's technical legal skills are excellent and his grasp of the regulatory casework is second to none.'

Leading Juniors

Scott Blair - Terra Firma Chambers 'Scott is extremely thorough in his opinions and court work.'
Ayla Iridag – Ampersand Advocates 'Ayla has an impressive ability to astutely appreciate and respond to tactical issues and decisions. Proactive in offering advice and assistance, she is a junior counsel whose ability exceeds her years of experience at the Bar.'
Barney Ross – Compass Chambers 'An advocate with a serene manner, who easily builds an excellent rapport with clients.'
Emma Toner - Compass Chambers 'Emma is an unflappable advocate, calm and pragmatic, with excellent client care skills.'
Clare Connelly – Compass Chambers 'Clare is able to analyse and assess the merits of any particular case or issue very quickly and decisively. Her advocacy is always measured, composed, and meticulously prepared.'
Carla Fraser - Compass Chambers 'A very reliable junior, whose opinions are equally well-reasoned and succinct.'
Jennifer Nicholson-White – Ampersand Advocates 'Jennifer is an extremely industrious junior.'

Rising Stars

Jonathan Deans – Arnot Manderson Advocates 'Jonathan has an astonishingly comprehensive knowledge of the law in criminal appeal work. His very detailed preparation, and his clear and exact written work, supports his powerful advocacy skills.'
Kenneth Young – Terra Firma Chambers 'Kenneth is very responsive and very thorough in his work. A very high quality advocate.'

Crime and regulatory in Scottish Bar

Ampersand Advocates


At Ampersand Advocates, multiple members of the stable have been kept especially busy representing various parties in the high-profile UK and Scottish COVID-19 inquiries, as well as acting for core participants in the Scottish Hospitals inquiry; in the case of the latter, Una Doherty KC is advising NHS National Services Scotland, while Susanne Tanner KC is representing Scottish Futures Trust in the ongoing proceedings. Simon Bowie KC ‘gets to the nub of the issue‘ in complex, prominent inquiries. Paul Reid KC has a solid track record in advising on prison-related litigation, and is often instructed in Fatal Accident Inquiries arising from deaths in custody. At the junior end of the stable, Ayla Iridag is well known for appearing for participants in Fatal Accident Inquiries, and acted as sole counsel to NHS Grampian in the fatal accident inquiry into the death of an 83-year old man, who died as a result of injuries inflicted by a person who had been referred for psychiatric treatment but had not attended the appointments; it was found that no health care precautions could reasonably have been taken that could have avoided the man’s death. In a boost to the stable, James McConnell KC and Usman Tariq KC were appointed to silk in September 2024.

Les références

Alan Moffat is second to none.’

Alan Moffat is a great leader of the Ampersand clerking team. Sensible and approachable.’

The service of the clerks is efficient, friendly and very responsive. Sheena Hume is particularly helpful and responsive.’





Compass Chambers


Compass Chambers is ‘the go-to stable for health and safety in Scotland‘, according to clients, and attracts praise as ‘one of the first choice stables for inquiry and reparation work‘. The ‘superbBarry Smith KC’s ‘performance in court is first-rate‘ and he is highly regarded for his expertise in advising on high-profile health and safety cases, often for maritime sector clients, as well as acting in Fatal Accident Inquiries. Peter Gray KC is ‘unflappable on his feet‘ and ‘highly effective and eloquent‘, with an excellent track record in handling complex regulatory criminal work and health and safety instructions. In a high-profile case, Murdo MacLeod KC and the ‘assured and conciseEmma Toner acted in the M9 fatal accident inquiry into the deaths of a couple in a car accident in 2015, after a 999 call reporting the accident was missed leading to their crashed car not being found for three days. MacLeod KC, Gray KC, Toner, and Barney Ross are also appearing for various parties in the Scottish Hospitals inquiry and the ongoing Scottish and UK COVID-19 public inquiries. Gavin Anderson KC is currently serving as an Advocate Depute.

Les références

Gavin Herd is particularly impressive.’

Gavin and the team are very professional and prompt in dealing with matters.’

Always excellent, the support from the clerks is consistently good.’





Terra Firma Chambers


At Terra Firma Chambers, Fred Mackintosh KC has ‘strength and depth of knowledge‘ in human rights matters, and is very well known for his expertise in handling cases involving secure environments. Alasdair Burnet KC has a solid track record in acting in high-profile public inquiries and for the NHS in Fatal Accident Inquiries, and is currently representing NHS Lothian in the ongoing Scottish Hospitals inquiry. At the junior end of the stable, Scott Blair is appearing as junior counsel in the ongoing Scottish Child Abuse inquiry, and Graham Dunlop and Kenneth Young are involved in the Scottish COVID-19 inquiry.

Les références

Emma Caskie-Potter is excellent – knows her counsel, works exceptionally well with solicitors and is very personable and responsive. The team behind her have equally high standards.’

Extremely helpful. Always engaged and engaging.’

Terra Firma is one of the best stables to deal with.’