Hall Of Fame

Clinical negligence: claimant in South West

Barcan+Kirby LLP

Lauded as ‘one of the best clinical negligence teams in the South West’, Barcan+Kirby LLP harnesses a deep bench of experts to undertake complex injury cases, notably concerning cerebral palsy, head and spinal injuries and fatal accidents. The Bristol team is spearheaded by Richard Harries, a highly respected practitioner with over two decades of experience representing clients in high-value clinical negligence cases involving late diagnoses, severe birth injuries and surgical negligence. Jay Nathwani leverages ‘a very impressive knowledge of the sector’, specialising in complex brain injury claims; cerebral palsy-expert Helen Franklin is recommended for her ‘great empathy’ towards clients; and the ‘superb’ Charlotte Tracy handles a wide range of claims, including birth injuries and fatal accidents, with a particular focus on cases involving paediatrics and obstetrics. Consultant Claire Hurrell is a key contact for matters relating to brain damage during birth or in the neonatal period, and ‘fearless litigator’ Fiona Dabell also comes recommended.

Responsables de la pratique:

Richard Harries


Autres avocats clés:

Jay Nathwani; Helen Franklin; Claire Hurrell; Charlotte Tracy; Fiona Dabell


Les références

‘Richard Harries heads up a very strong clinical negligence team. The attention to detail and legal knowledge makes this one of the best clinical negligence teams in the South West.’

‘Charlotte Tracy is a superb lawyer. She is professional and robust with defendants, whilst being kind and compassionate to her clients. Fiona Dabell is a fearless litigator who always obtains great settlements.’

‘The team at Barcan+Kirby are dedicated to achieving the best outcomes for their clients. They form sensitive, professional relationships with their clients who have often been badly injury and have a loss of trust in the medical profession.’

Clarke Willmott LLP

Operating at the ‘cutting edge of clinical negligence work’, the team at Clarke Willmott LLP represents claimants in a wide range of maximum severity cases, involving birth injuries, complex surgical errors and delayed diagnoses. The firm is also noted for its inquest practice, with practice head Marguarita Tyne leading on complex dependency and fatal injury claims, as well as loss of fertility and surrogacy issues. Kerry Fifield specialises in birth and paediatric cases, while Vanessa Harris stands out for her expertise in OASI and maternal birth injuries. Taunton-based James Edmondson is recommended for going ‘above and beyond’ in surgical negligence cases, with Court of Appeal and Supreme Court experience. Isabel Harper is another name to note. All practitioners are based in Bristol unless otherwise stated.

Responsables de la pratique:

Marguarita Tyne


Autres avocats clés:

Kerry Fifield; Vanessa Harris; James Edmondson; Isabel Harper


Les références

‘The clinical negligence team will ensure comprehensive and diligent investigation of all case issues, to secure the best possible settlement for the client. My impression is that clients always receive a personal touch, and continuity in service, from solicitors that are both experienced and talented. Importantly, they understand how to bring a claim to a fair and efficient conclusion.’

‘Vanessa Harris stands out, she is experienced, talented and compassionate. It is obvious that she really cares about her clients, and will relentlessly strive for the best possible outcome for them. I always find Vanessa responsive and reliable, and I have observed her achieve excellent results for clients. I would not hesitate to recommend her to a potential client.’

‘Clarke Willmott are very professional with the service they provide. They are very confident with the work they do and the communication skills from the team both verbally and written are excellent. They constantly keep you in the loop with every little step. Over the past few years I have been very happy with the service I have been provided and cannot recommend Clarke Willmott enough!’

Enable Law

‘Replete with depth and expertise’, Enable Law‘s renowned clinical negligence practice is well equipped to advise clients on the full spectrum of claims, with a sizeable team of specialists in birth injuries, neonatal death, delayed diagnosis of cancer and catastrophic stroke cases. The firm’s South West offering spans multiple offices, with practice head Robert Antrobus leading on birth injury and meningitis claims in Plymouth; Bristol-based Gillian Clark handling birth injuries, and Paul Sankey achieving ‘excellent results’ for claims involving medical consent and negligent treatment by health professionals, while Mike Bird handles brain and spine injury claims in Cornwall. In Exeter, Michelle Biddulph heads up the national clinical negligence team, leading on complex, maximum severity cases. Other key names are Claire Stoneman, Jackie Linehan, Alex McKnight and Claire Leslie.

Responsables de la pratique:

Robert Antrobus; Michelle Biddulph


Autres avocats clés:

Paul Sankey; Mike Bird; Gillian Clark; Claire Stoneman; Paula Barnes; Claire Leslie; Jackie Linehan; Alex McKnight; Frances Wright


Les références

‘The best regional clinical negligence firm in the South West.’

‘Very highly regarded in the South West. Replete with depth and experience. Undertake high quality work on serious cases.’

‘Michelle Biddulph is a very fine lawyer. Mike Bird is very popular with clients and has a fantastic practice.’

Irwin Mitchell

The ‘first-rate’ medical negligence team at Irwin Mitchell has established a strong reputation in the South West, representing claimants in a wide range of high-value catastrophic injury cases. In Bristol, practice head Julie Lewis is regarded as a ‘standout star’, with a robust specialism in birth injury matters. Luke Trevorrow is noted for his work in group action litigation, representing clients in claims against both NHS and private healthcare providers, while Elise Burvill has expertise in delays in cancer diagnosis and fatal psychiatric cases. James Pink leverages ‘excellent client care skills’ across a wide spectrum of injury claims, often involving complex surgical injuries and stomas.

Responsables de la pratique:

Julie Lewis


Autres avocats clés:

Luke Trevorrow; Elise Burvill; James Pink


Les références

‘The Bristol team is one of the strongest clinical negligence teams in the city. Their strong legal knowledge, combined with excellent client care skills makes them hard to beat.’

‘James Pink is standout. His legal knowledge rivals that of any barrister and he has excellent client care skills, particularly for those with life-changing injuries.’

‘First-rate team with an impressive array of talent. They undertake the most valuable and complex work and get great results. The depth of experience across the team means they really are at the top of the tree both locally and nationally. Highly recommended.’

Principaux dossiers


  • Instructed to investigate a delay in diagnosis of cervical cancer by two General Practitioners and the adverse outcome on the claimant.
  • Instructed to investigate a failure to undertake preventative surgery after a stroke which resulted in a second fatal stroke months later.
  • Securing an admission of liability, interim payment and judgment against defendant trust for failings in respect of cervical screening and successful challenge to limitation defence.

RWK Goodman

RWK Goodman has a strong reputation for handling high-value clinical negligence claims in the South West, with notable specialisms in catastrophic birth injury and dental negligence cases. The Somerset-based team is led by Simon Elliman, who specialises in matters involving maximum severity spinal cord injuries and cauda equina syndrome, while Paul Rumley is highly regarded for settling high-value and complex birth injury claims. Other key names include Ali Batchelor, who handles complex inquests and fatal claims; Naomi Todd, who heads up the specialist dental negligence team; and the ‘exceptional’ Kerstin Scheel, who represents claimants in obstetric cases, notably involving cerebral palsy and Erb’s palsy. Associates Abigail Ringer and Hannah Blackwell also come recommended.

Responsables de la pratique:

Simon Elliman


Autres avocats clés:

Paul Rumley; Kerstin Scheel; Ali Batchelor; Naomi Todd; Hannah Blackwell; Abigail Ringer


Les références

‘The firm is excellent. They deal with inquests in medical cases and claims for damages in a wide range of cases including the very highest value.’

‘Kerstin Scheel: excellent solicitor, pragmatic, achieves excellent results for her clients. Abigail Ringer, very bright, very well-organised, excellent solicitor.’

‘RWK Goodman have the perfect balance of knowledge, understanding and experience in handling maximum value clinical negligence claims.’

Tozers Solicitors LLP

Spearheaded by Endurance Arthur, who is an esteemed specialist in birth-related injuries, Tozers Solicitors LLP is distinguished for its market-leading Erb’s palsy practice. Other key specialisms include infection claims, notably Group B Strep infections, as well as claims relating to brain injuries masked by therapeutic hypothermia in wrongful birth cases. Simon Mansfield represents claimants in a broad suite of high-value clinical negligence claims and inquests, while Clair Hemming specialises in catastrophic neurological injury claims involving Erb’s palsy. Michelle Beckett, Kate Stone and Helena Campbell are also key contacts for claims arising from delayed diagnoses, negligently performed surgeries and a range of obstetric issues.

Responsables de la pratique:

Endurance Arthur


Autres avocats clés:

Clair Hemming; Simon Mansfield; Michelle Beckett; Kate Stone; Helena Campbell


Principaux dossiers


  • Securing an admission of liability for a client who instructed the team to pursue damages for a catastrophic brain damage resulting from an undiagnosed fetal maternal haemorrhage in the period before his birth 19 years previously.
  • Securing damages of £850,000 (without an admission of liability) for a woman who suffered PTSD, depression and substantial loss of earnings as consequence of a very traumatic childbirth experience.
  • Securing a liability compromise for a client, pursuing an Erb’s palsy claim.

Coles Miller Solicitors LLP

The team at Coles Miller Solicitors LLP harnesses ‘extensive knowledge’ in a broad suite of clinical negligence issues, notably birth injuries, cauda equina syndrome and delays in diagnoses and misdiagnosis. The team is co-led by managing partner Adrian Cormack, a complex brain injury claims specialist, and David Simpson, who handles cases involving cauda equina, mismanaged labour and amputations. The ‘pragmatic’ Lydia Barnett comes recommended for her wide-ranging practice in complex and high-value claims, with notable expertise in secondary victim claims for psychiatric injury.

Responsables de la pratique:

Adrian Cormack; David Simpson


Autres avocats clés:

Lydia Barnett


Les références

‘Good communication. Will always try to get best outcome for claimant.’

‘Have worked with Lydia Barnett on several cases and she pays attention to detail.’

‘Very good communication from the team.’

Principaux dossiers


  • Represented claimant who suffered significant Post Traumatic Stress Disorder as a consequence of index injury and treatment.
  • Represented claimant following urological surgery with no reasonable prospects of a successful outcome leading to multiple subsequent surgeries. In total 12 surgeries ought to have been avoided.
  • Represented claimant who alleged mismanaged labour in respect of pre-eclampsia and significantly raised blood pressure which resulted in the claimant suffering an acute, near total hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury prior to his birth.

Coodes Solicitors

The clinical negligence team at Coodes Solicitors has a robust birth injury practice, representing claimants in high-value cases involving cerebral palsy, stillbirths and neonatal deaths. The team has additional specialisms in fatal accidents and mental health issues, representing clients at inquests concerning preventable suicides of psychiatric patients. Rachel Pearce leads the Falmouth-based practice, acting for clients in birth injury, misdiagnosis and surgical error claims. The ‘very experienced’ Julie Hatton is highlighted for her expertise in obstetrics and gynaecology cases, acting in both litigation and mediation.

Responsables de la pratique:

Rachel Pearce


Autres avocats clés:

Julie Hatton


Les références

‘They stay professional but have empathy and compassion. They are always aware of updates on the case and let us know in a timely manner.’

‘Julie Hatton always tries her best, she goes above and beyond to find the best experts in the field.’

‘Good regional firm.’

Principaux dossiers


  • Secured a £1.1m immediate damages award plus provisional damages for a 22-year old who suffered kidney failure and a mild brain injury at birth.
  • Represented a claim brought on behalf of the estate following the death of a 43-year-old man from a heart attack shortly after undergoing heart surgery in October 2019.
  • Represented a client in a claim for a delayed diagnosis of slipped upper femoral epiphysis (thigh bone), resulting in her needing a total hip replacement at 17 instead of less invasive treatment.

Slee Blackwell

Slee Blackwell‘s clinical negligence team combines an ‘unwavering commitment to excellence’ with a client-centric approach to represent claimants in the South West and throughout the UK. With offices in Barnstaple and Taunton, the team handles a variety of claims, including birth injury, cosmetic surgery and high-profile mesh litigation. In Barnstaple, Oliver Thorne spearheads the practice, specialising in cases involving baby loss and birth injury, with a particular focus on maternal rights. Working between Barnstaple and Taunton, the ‘exceptional’ Caroline Webber-Brown is highlighted for her expertise in complex mesh litigation and gynaecological negligence, supported by Taunton-based associate Clarissa Ellerington.

Responsables de la pratique:

Oliver Thorne


Autres avocats clés:

Caroline Webber-Brown; Clarissa Ellerington


Les références

‘Caroline Webber-Brown and her team at Slee Blackwell were exceptional!’

‘I worked Clarissa Ellerington, who was a stalwart throughout an emotive and challenging process. She proved to be an able and empathetic listener but who was always efficient and positive.’

‘Oliver Thorne and his team provided clear understanding of our legal position, but with a compassion and understanding of our emotional state. They were there from the start, through all the legal wrangles, through the inquest and the final claim. Frankly, we were blessed to have them, because although they were always highly professional, they showed real empathy and consideration.’

Principaux dossiers


  • Represented client in cerebral palsy claim where the client’s mother was given syntocinon instead of a saline infusion prior to a planned caesarean section. Mother suffered from a placental abruption meaning and emergency caesarean section under general anaesthetic was needed. Client suffered from hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE) and went on to develop cerebral palsy.
  • Investigated a failure to interpret an MRI from 2015, leading to a delayed diagnosis of a meningioma, causing permanent vision loss and severe neurological damage.

Thompsons Solicitors LLP

Thompsons Solicitors LLP harnesses a network of clinical negligence specialists across its national offering, acting as ‘ruthless advocates’ for clients in the South West and throughout the UK. Key specialisms of the team include birth injuries and delayed diagnosis, alongside a particularly strong mesh-related litigation practice. The ‘excellent’ Sabeena Pirooz leads the Bristol office, handling the full spectrum of clinical negligence claims.

Responsables de la pratique:

Sabeena Pirooz


Les références

‘Sophisticated, diverse, responsive.’

‘Ruthless advocates for their clients. Very efficient.’

‘Sabeena Pirooz is excellent. I would highly recommend her.’

Wolferstans

The dedicated clinical negligence practice at Wolferstans in highlighted for its ‘great strength in depth’, with a sizeable team of practitioners specialising in a wide range of claims. In Plymouth, Elizabeth Smith heads up the team, providing ‘excellent legal analysis’ to cases involving brain injuries; while Peter Tassart harnesses expertise in spinal injuries and amputation claims; and Barry Bayley and Holly Bowditch specialise in brain and birth injury cases. James Snell is noted for his ‘great eye for detail’, handling claims involving orthopaedic injuries and conditions affecting the ears, nose and throat.

Responsables de la pratique:

Elizabeth Smith


Autres avocats clés:

Barry Bayley; Holly Bowditch; Peter Tassart; James Snell


Les références

‘I have worked extensively with Elizabeth Smith. She is excellent and her supporting team are of a very high quality.’

‘Elizabeth Smith is extremely responsive, excellent legal analysis, always proactive and one step ahead.’

‘I work mostly with Barry Bayley, who specialises in complex, high-value claims. Barry marries technical excellence and strong commercial acumen with high emotional intelligence and compassion to secure his clients the best result that he can. Barry understands his cases and his clients inside out, and it is a pleasure to work with him on those cases.’

Principaux dossiers


  • Settled a complex spinal injury claim following investigation of liability and quantum.

Lyons Davidson

Lyons Davidson offers a ‘first-rate service’ to clients in clinical negligence claims, ranging from low-value to maximum severity injuries and catastrophic incidents. In Bristol, the clinical negligence practice falls within the firm’s expansive civil division, with team lead Joanna Laidlaw specialising in child brain injury cases. Tabitha Rooks is recommended for high-value clinical negligence claims, noted for obtaining ‘great results’ for clients. Associate Sana Akram handles a broad range of cases, involving stroke, amputation and birth injury issues.

Responsables de la pratique:

Joanna Laidlaw; Tabitha Rooks


Autres avocats clés:

Sana Akram


Les références

‘Lyons Davidson provide an excellent service to clinical negligence clients. The team is well run and impressive and gets some great results. They have scale to undertake the most serious cases and the talent to provide a first rate service to their clients.’

‘Tabitha Rook is a impressive individual with huge experience and a first-rate legal mind. She provides great leadership and gets great results.’

‘Joanna Laidlaw is very experienced, tactically astute and sound judgment. She is also hard working.’

Red Kite Law LLP

The clinical negligence offering at Red Kite Law LLP was significantly bolstered by the arrival of Madeleine Pinschof in 2024, who now heads up the Cirencester practice. Pinschof is highly regarded as a ‘superb legal mind’ with extensive expertise in the full spectrum of clinical negligence cases. Notable specialisms include cerebral palsy and other brain injury cases, as well as leveraging considerable mesh litigation experience.

Responsables de la pratique:

Madeleine Pinschof


Les références

‘Madeleine Pinschof is an excellent solicitor. She is well organised, efficient and highly knowledgeable.’

‘Madeleine Pinschof has extensive experience of clinical negligence in obstetrics and gynaecology. She is a pleasure to work with, being persistent and always determined to get the best settlement for her clients.’

‘Madeleine Pinshchof is a superb legal mind and a pleasure to work with.’

Principaux dossiers


  • Advisinga client in a liability admitted case where client sustained cerebral palsy and brain injury that will impact her entire life.
  • Advising a client, who at the 20 week scan while invitro was diagnosed with a congenital pulmonary airway malformation. He requires surgery but that surgery was negligently performed leaving him with the loss of a lung which may result in long term difficulties and possible reduction on life expectancy.
  • Advising a client who, at 9 years of age, underwent heart surgery during which she suffered an ischaemic injury to her right leg as a result of an arterial line being inappropriately labelled.

Trethowans LLP

Operating across offices in Salisbury, Poole and Southampton, the team at Trethowans LLP leverages ‘great strength and depth’ to represent clients in wide-ranging, high-value claims. Southampton-based John Hall leads the team, comprised of specialists in cases involving cerebral palsy, birth injuries, surgical negligence and delayed diagnoses. The ‘immensely capable and hardworking’ James Braund heads up the Poole office, with notable expertise in claims relating to spinal and head injuries, amputations and other catastrophic injuries.

Responsables de la pratique:

John Hall


Autres avocats clés:

James Braund


Les références

‘Great strength and depth, great presence geographically and good name. Excellent lawyers that fight hard for clients and always look after their clients really well.’

‘James Braund is an excellent partner. Knows the law inside and out.’

‘Good bench strength and dedicated and insightful team of practitioners.’

Trowers & Hamlins LLP

Trowers & Hamlins LLP ‘delivers an exceptional service’ to claimants in clinical negligence matters, with notable experience in cross-border cases. As a sub-specialism within the firm’s travel, tourism and insurance practice, the Exeter-based team is co-led by Bronwen Courtenay-Stamp and Tom Sampford. Sampford harnesses experience acting for both claimants and defendants, with strong expertise in cases relating to birth injuries, spinal injuries and delays in cancer diagnoses.

Responsables de la pratique:

Tom Sampford; Bronwen Courtenay-Stamp


Les références

‘The clinical negligence team at Trowers are superb. They are set apart from their competitors in that their clinical negligence work extends to cross-border cases, such as in the Isle of Man, Jersey and Guernsey. They consistently deliver an exceptional service.’

‘Tom Sampford is excellent. He is committed to achieving the very best results for his clients. He leaves no stone unturned in his cases and often achieves fantastic results.’

Principaux clients

Arc Legal Assistance Limited


Mapfre


Collinson Group


Wollens

The ‘balanced, strong and hardworking team’ at Wollens represents clients in the full breadth of clinical negligence claims, garnering a particularly strong reputation for its specialism in claims involving delays in the diagnosis or misdiagnosis of cancer. At the helm, Elizabeth Larner is highlighted for her ‘unparalleled’ client care, leading on high-value surgical error, delay and misdiagnosis claims. Catherine Pinnegar specialises in delayed diagnosis and fatal injury cases, alongside an expanding inquest practice, while Hannah Goodman is noted for her expertise in cosmetic surgery claims.

Responsables de la pratique:

Elizabeth Larner


Autres avocats clés:

Catherine Pinnegar; Hannah Goodman


Les références

‘Elizabeth Larner is unparalleled in the client care that she gives. From first instructing Wollens on a very complex clinical negligence case, Elizabeth has been exceptional in the service that she has performed and has dealt with me in a most caring and thoughtful manner. She has been more I than I could have ever have wished for in a solicitor taking on my claim.’

‘Elizabeth Larner runs an incredibly tight ship where the client is at the centre of everything.’

‘Working in the field of clinical negligence is not just a job to Elizabeth Larner, it is a vocation and a passion. Elizabeth Larner is the beating heart of Wollens’ clinical negligence team.’