The ‘responsive, reassuring and highly astute’ team at Brodies LLP advises key public and private entities across the transportation, maritime, energy and construction sectors. Clare Bone leads the practice, and is noted for her strong track record in handling fatal accident inquiries and HSE investigations, drawing on her past experience as a prosecutor. Malcolm Gunnyeon excels at transport and energy safety litigation, while Victoria Anderson is noted for her corporate expertise, advising on internal investigations and compliance. Ramsey Hall left the firm in September 2024.
Health and safety in Scotland
Brodies LLP
Responsables de la pratique:
Clare Bone
Autres avocats clés:
Malcolm Gunnyeon; Victoria Anderson; Paul Marshall; Amy Anderson
Les références
‘Malcolm Gunnyeon typically turns around initial instructions on the day they are given. This is impressive and helps us greatly in meeting our own clients’ expectations.’
‘The team from Brodies clearly explained the situation we were in and provided their detailed plan of action to guide us to the best possible solution. When you find yourself in a difficult situation, you need a legal team that listens to your concerns and opinions and is readily available. With the Brodies team, we were reassured by their clear thinking.’
‘The health & safety team at Brodies are responsive, reassuring and highly astute.’
Principaux clients
Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
Rathburn Chemicals
Pentland Ferries
RJ McLeod
Merchant Homes Ltd(in liquidation)
Lt Col and WO2, HM Armed Forces
Principaux dossiers
- Representing RJ Macleod (Contractors) Limited at a Fatal Accident Inquiry following the death of a 10-year-old boy who fell down a manhole on its site.
- Acting for two serving members of the armed forces at a Fatal Accident Inquiry following the death of a student at a sniper training course at Tain Air Weapons Range.
- Advising Network Rail in relation to the Fatal Accident Inquiry in relation to a train derailment near Stonehaven in August 2020.
BTO Solicitors LLP
The ‘extremely proactive’ team at BTO Solicitors LLP is well-placed to advise on investigations and regulatory compliance, assisting clients in the construction, hospitality and manufacturing sectors. Under the purview of Vikki Watt, the team handles fatal accident inquiries, employment tribunal claims and HSE issues. Lindsay MacNeill is particularly experienced in advising on high-profile accidents. Other key figures within the team include Neil Macdonald and the ‘excellent’ Ramsey Hall, who joined the team from Brodies LLP in September 2024.
Responsables de la pratique:
Vikki Watt
Autres avocats clés:
Lindsay Macneill; Ramsey Hall; Neil Macdonald
Les références
‘Neil Macdonald has been extremely professional and considerate in our dealings with him.’
‘We have found the team to be very helpful and efficient in dealing with our case.’
‘The team has been extremely proactive and accommodating. Very approachable, excellent at putting people at ease & able to decipher legal speak into lay persons’ English to ensure the client fully understands the legal options open to them.’
Principaux clients
HC One
Glasgow City Council
AIG Europe Uk Ltd
Rublane Ltd
NG Bailey Ltd
Oilfast Ltd
Manor Hotel Stornoway Ltd
NFU Mutual UK Ltd
Alan Paxton
CHUBB
AXA XL
AVIVA
Principaux dossiers
- Acted in the Joe Spencer Fatal Accident Inquiry involving a military fatality on exercise, the Shea Ryan FAI involving the death of a child at a construction site in Glasgow, and in a train derailment FAI following a catastrophic rail incident.
- Represented NG Bailey Ltd in a prosecution following a death of an operative at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
- Acted for an individual prosecuted for causing a fatality under Section 7 of the HSWA 1974 and successfully avoided the imposition of a custodial sentence on the client with the interests of justice served by the imposition of a £1,000 fine.
Anderson Strathern
The team at Anderson Strathern has broad regulatory expertise, advising both public bodies and private clients. Under the supervision of Sarah Phillips, the practice stands out for its vast public, maritime and transport law, with a strong focus on fatal accident inquiries, Covid-19 investigations and the appeals of prohibitory notice. Phillips is noted for her strong background in personal injury litigation, advising clients on liability and indemnity issues. Julia McDonald ‘communicates efficiently’ with companies looking to improve their internal safety procedures, while Calum Sweeney is experienced in advising on technical enforcement notices.
Responsables de la pratique:
Sarah Phillips
Autres avocats clés:
Julia Mcdonald; Calum Sweeney
Les références
‘Julia MacDonald is excellent to work with. She works well with the HSE in Fatal Accident Inquiries and communicates efficiently with the Crown in delivering statements and coordinating witness involvement for the regulator.’
‘Anderson Strathern has a very strong practice acting on behalf of public bodies for health and safety work.’
‘Calum Sweeney is a go-to for dealing with complex legal issues and explaining them in a way that is easy to understand. He works on very technical enforcement notices appeals in a straightforward and pragmatic way.’
Principaux clients
Scottish Prison Service
Office of the Advocate General for Scotland
Health and Safety Executive
The Scottish Government
Norit (UK) Limited
Scottish Canals
Offshore Petroleum Regulator for Environment and Decommissioning
The University of Strathclyde
Scottish Water
Scottish Midland Co-operative Society Limited (Scotmid)
Scottish Courts and Tribunal Service
Scottish Prison Service
Office of the Advocate General for Scotland
Health and Safety Executive
The Scottish Government
Norit (UK) Limited
Scottish Canals
Offshore Petroleum Regulator for Environment and Decommissioning
The University of Strathclyde
Scottish Water
Scottish Midland Co-operative Society Limited (Scotmid)
Scottish Courts and Tribunal Service
Principaux dossiers
- Conducted numerous enforcement notice appeals on behalf of the HSE.
- Conducted numerous FAIs including on behalf of the SPS, private clients and HSE.
- Conducted numerous FAIs including on behalf of the SPS, private clients and HSE.
Burness Paull LLP
Lynne Gray offers ‘incredibly clear and pragmatic advice’ as head of Burness Paull LLP‘s health and safety team, providing support at the site of accidents, and representing clients in personal injury claims. The team has a strong reputation in the energy and care sectors, and is particularly adept at handling maritime investigation accidents and construction claims. Gray excels at crisis management whilst Lynne Moss frequently works on liability and compliance matters. The ‘super responsive’ Eilidh McSherry is a key figure within the practice.
Responsables de la pratique:
Lynne Gray
Autres avocats clés:
Lynne Moss; Eilidh Mcsherry
Les références
‘Fantastic market knowledge and awareness of current trends and action by the HSE in the sector. Very client friendly at all levels within an organisation from CEO down to more junior.’
‘Lynne Gray is very client friendly, offering incredibly clear and pragmatic advice.’
‘Eilidh McSherry is a really good junior lawyer. She is a super responsive and clear advisor.’
Principaux clients
Repsol Resources
TotalEnergies
Apache North Sea
Mercury Engineering
VSA
Sunderland Marine
Arnold Clark
Sanctuary
Key Properties Solutions
Principaux dossiers
- Acting for Hebridean Island Cruises in connection with the maritime tragedy which occurred on the river Clyde in February 2023 – the sinking of the tug Biter with the loss of its crew.
- Advising an offshore energy company in an investigation that is being carried out by the HSE Energy Division of the Offshore Major Accident Regulator into an offshore incident that occurred on a FPSO in the North Sea when a major hydrocarbon gas release occurred during depressurisation of a section of pipeline.
- Representing Key Properties in defending criminal proceedings following a gas release from a low-pressure mains pipe during construction works at Fort Kinnaird retail park in Edinburgh in June 2019.
Clyde & Co
The team at Clyde & Co frequently advises clients on workplace fatality and injury investigations in the shipping, construction, transportation and insurance sectors. Mark Donaldson spearheads the team, leveraging his extensive personal injury litigation expertise, and his experience in appearing before the Sherriff Courts and the Courts of Session. Ann Bonomy has deep knowledge of road and traffic investigations, while Julie Brodtkorb is noted for providing ‘excellent service'.
Responsables de la pratique:
Mark Donaldson
Autres avocats clés:
Ann Bonomy; Julie Brodtkorb; Kimberley Mitchell
Les références
‘Ann Bonomy has a wealth of knowledge and experience, which makes her a stand-out choice when looking for legal advice.’
‘The team is very experienced with a depth of knowledge and clear understanding.’
‘I would highly recommend Clyde & Co to anyone seeking professional legal advice or assistance. ’
Principaux clients
A & R Services
AIG
Allianz
Andrew Roger – Cameron House
Anywind Energias Renováveis, Lda
Chubb
Co-operative Group Ltd
Core Cut Ltd
Edinburgh Carpet Warehouse
Edinburgh Trams Ltd
Edmundson Electrical
Diageo
G & A Leask
Global Energy Nigg Ltd
GS Robertson Ltd
Hall & Tawse
Kairdson Tyres
Leiths Scotland
O’Mac Construction
Orkney Islands Council
QBE
WN Lindsay
Zurich
XDP Ltd
Principaux dossiers
- Acted for a construction company in relation to a double fatality and serious injuries to two other employees in a tragic workplace incident.
- Acted for a company in relation to health and safety investigations and a prosecution following a tragic workplace fatality.
- Represented a company at a Fatal Accident Inquiry following the tragic death of an employee in a work-related incident.
Pinsent Masons LLP
Pinsent Masons LLP advises on a wide range of health and safety matters, ranging from fatal accident inquiries, HSE compliance, and Covid-19 investigations. The team acts for both public and privately traded corporations in the energy, shipping and transportation industries. Katherine Metcalfe is noted for her expertise in the fire and building safety space, whilst Bruce Craig stands out due to his vast maritime expertise.
Responsables de la pratique:
Kevin Bridges
Autres avocats clés:
Katherine Metcalfe; Bruce Craig; Willie Park
Les références
‘Katherine Metcalfe was a consummate professional with a willingness to engage and work with us to develop the scenarios that we used in the mock trials.’
‘The team was exceptional, providing an invaluable source of expert advice and support. The whole team acted with transparency delivering excellent advice in a thoughtful manner that made a real difference.’
‘We used Katherine Metcalfe and her team for a challenging case. The team went the extra mile, diligently keeping us informed every set of the way.’
Principaux clients
Shell UK
Balfour Beatty Group
BAM Nuttall Limited
Peel Ports
Galliford Try
University of Edinburgh
Transocean
Valaris
Diamond Offshore Drilling
Celtic Plc
MacFarlan Smith
City of Edinburgh Council
British Marine
TT Club
Skuld
Petrofac Facilities Management
Principaux dossiers
Addleshaw Goddard
Addleshaw Goddard focuses on both public and fatal accident inquiries, assisting both private corporations and public bodies across the transportation, healthcare and construction sectors. Lisa Mcneill leads the Scottish arm of the team, and acts in national public inquiries. Abby Housego regularly acts in health and safety litigation.
Responsables de la pratique:
Lisa McNeill
Autres avocats clés:
Abby Housego
Les références
‘Great understanding of public inquiry processes and ability to bring together a team with the relevant experience to advise the client organisation, and support individual witnesses through a stressful process.’
‘Lisa McNeill has been particularly responsive and she is able to provide valuable advice to the organisation as well as supporting individual witnesses.’
Principaux clients
Scottish Futures Trust
Light Rail Safety Standards Board (LRSSB) and UKTram
Principaux dossiers
- Acting in the Scottish Covid-19 Inquiry for Scottish Enterprise, The Scottish Hospitals Inquiry for Scottish Futures Trust and The Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry for Kibble Education and Care Centre.
- Advising UK Tram and Light Rail Safety and Standards Board in relation to their position as an Interested Party in the Fatal Accident Inquiry set up to look at the death of an individual.
DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP is reputed for the depth of its expertise in the insurance sector, and is well-equipped to handle the full gamut of health and safety work. The practice is spearheaded by Karen Railton, who acts in Fatal Accident Inquiries, Covid-19 safety investigations and legislative compliance. Railton possesses a wealth of regulatory knowledge whilst Zoe McDonnell is noted for her expertise in contentious work.
Responsables de la pratique:
Karen Railton
Autres avocats clés:
Zoe McDonnell; Alasdair Irvine
Les références
‘As a team DAC provides a very professional and competent service to clients, it is fully integrated and works together very well in providing not only expert legal advice from highly experienced practitioners but also great client service.’
‘The team led by Karen Railton has strength in depth. Karen is an experienced litigation lawyer and a great team manager. Alastair Irvine is a dedicated and talented lawyer.’
‘The DAC Beachcroft Team is the largest dedicated regulatory team in Scotland, specialising in H&S across all industry areas.’
Principaux clients
AXA
AXA Corporate Solutions
AXA XL
AIG
Admiral
Zurich
Zurich Municipal
Aviva
QBE
Allianz
NFU Mutual
Liberty Global
HDI Global
Tesco Underwriting
Police Scotland
Scottish Police Authority
HC-One Limited
Tesco Stores Limited
Scottish Water
West Fraser Europe Limited
Robertson Construction Group
Springfield Group plc
Glasgow City Council
Covea Insurance
Principaux dossiers
- Advising and rolling out a substantive and bespoke Behavioural Safety Training package to every employee of a national Utilities provider, a national public body, from the Director to the operative level.
- Acting for one of the UK’s largest national care home operators in relation to various high profile fatalities including multiple fatality Covid-19 outbreaks at their various care home services throughout the country, and an independent fatal health and safety incident.
- Acting as the sole provider of legal advice and representation in all health and safety matters. The employee of a subcontractor died while working on the construction of a defence facility at Rosyth dockyard, where the client was the principal contractor on the project.
Levy & McRae
Levy & McRae excels at handling contentious health and safety work, and is capable of assisting corporations and private individuals with all matters relating to investigations. The practice is jointly led by Callum Anderson and Ray Gribben, leveraging its extensive knowledge of civil and criminal law to assist clients. Gribben possesses extensive regulatory knowledge whilst Anderson stands out for his expertise in logistics and transport cases.
Responsables de la pratique:
Callum Anderson; Ray Gribben
Les références
‘Levy and McRae adapted to the situation and stepped up to support.’
‘Both Callum Anderson and Ray Gribben have in-depth knowledge of this area of work, are highly experienced and effective in achieving best results for clients.’
‘Team members were available and supportive.’
Principaux dossiers
- Acting for 15 employees of security in a regulatory investigation by the Security Industry Authority. No charges or proceedings were brought against any of the employees.
- Acting on behalf of an all-trades contractor in the relation to the death of an employee who fell from a ladder. The firm was able to persuade the Crown not to proceed with a criminal prosecution following engagement with the HSE investigation.
- Acting on behalf of a security company who was providing security on a large construction site where a young child was tragically involved in a fatal accident. The firm was able to persuade the Crown not to prosecute the client in this case.
Morton Fraser MacRoberts
Morton Fraser MacRoberts routinely appears before civil and criminal courts, acting as prosecutors, board advisors and HSE representatives on behalf of both public bodies and private corporations alike. The practice, which is headed by Jenny Dickson, often assists with initial investigations after traumatic incidents, fatal accident inquiries and prosecutions. Dickson regularly handles investigations after major transport accidents whilst Nicola Edgar leverages her extensive personal injury experience to assist clients.
Responsables de la pratique:
Jenny Dickson
Autres avocats clés:
Nicola Edgar; David Hossak; Robyn Keay
Les références
‘They understand their clients’ needs and aspirations and are sensitive to client concerns.’
‘Nicola Edgar is a partner heading up inquiries who has an understanding of client objectives.’
‘Nicola Edgar is an iron fist in a silken glove.’
Principaux clients
Ministry of Defence
Comhairle nan Eilean Siar (Western Isles Council)
Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB)
Scottish Government
Historic Environment Scotland
Health & Safety Executive
Police Scotland
Royal Mail Group Limited
Arnold Clark Automobiles Limited
Scottish Wildlife Trust
Principaux dossiers
- Acting on behalf of Ministry of Defence in a Fatal Accident Inquiry following the death of LCpl Spencer, when his firearm was accidentally discharged during a training exercise.
- Acting on behalf of the Rail Accident Investigation Branch in a Fatal Accident Inquiry into the fatal tram collision that occurred at Saughton tram crossing in Edinburgh.
- Providing training to the Scottish Government on relevant health & safety considerations for their Warmer Homes Scheme.
rradar
rradar’s wide-ranging practice encompasses fatal accident inquiries, national public inquiries, HSE investigations and regulatory appeals. The team, which is led by Alastair Gray, is particularly active in the construction, healthcare and hospitality industries. Gray is a respected litigator with extensive knowledge of health and safety, environmental and traffic regulations, allowing him to utilise a multidisciplinary approach. Key members of the team include David Fitzpatrick, an investigations specialist, and Sarah MacArthur, who works on public inquiries and negligence cases.
Responsables de la pratique:
Alastair Gray
Autres avocats clés:
David Fitzpatrick; Sarah MacArthur
Les références
‘Rradar solicitors is a unique and innovative legal practice that stands out in several key areas. What makes Rradar unique is its integration of legal expertise with cutting-edge digital tools to proactively educate, manage, advise, and deliver business solutions aimed at reducing legal risk.’
‘The team is known for its empathetic approach, working closely with clients to minimise harm and prevent the recurrence of issues.’
‘Rradar Solicitors is renowned for its exceptional technical capability, which spans the entire claim lifecycle, from triage to resolution.’
Principaux clients
Central Demolition Ltd
Keane Premier Group Ltd
Oakminster Healthcare Ltd
Thistle Healthcare Ltd
Principaux dossiers
- Represented Central Demolition Ltd in connection with the fatality of a contractor who died during demolition work at the St Enoch Centre, Glasgow in September 2019.
- Representing the interests of Thistle Healthcare Ltd in relation to both Operation Koper and the Scottish COVID-19 Inquiry. The client operates a number of care and nursing homes throughout Scotland.
- Representing the interests of Oakminster Healthcare Ltd in relation to both Operation Koper and the Scottish COVID-19 Inquiry. The client operates a number of care and nursing homes throughout Scotland.