Brodies LLP fields a ‘very professional, knowledgable and approachable’ team of regulatory defence specialists, with Clare Bone leading the practice from Glasgow. Bone supports clients from the initial stages of incident investigations through to the conclusion of court proceedings, while Aberdeen-based Malcolm Gunnyeon is active in the energy and transport sector, focusing on major incident response, fatal accident inquiries, and defending against prosecutions related to breaches of health and safety legislation. In Edinburgh, Paul Marshall offers advice to clients in the oil and gas, construction, and manufacturing industries facing investigations and prosecutions following significant incidents, and senior associate Victoria Anderson focuses on health and safety regulatory investigations and prosecutions.
Health and safety in Scotland
Brodies LLP
Responsables de la pratique:
Clare Bone
Autres avocats clés:
Malcolm Gunnyeon; Paul Marshall; Victoria Anderson; Ramsey Hall
Les références
‘Every single person I have dealt with has been professional, courteous, extremely helpful and are always there when I need them. I would highly recommend them to anyone considering using legal advice.’
‘Victoria Anderson has been exceptional and extremely helpful, and she is always there when I need her. I would highly recommend Victoria to any Client seeking H&S advice.’
‘Excellent industry and technical knowledge, helpful practical advice.’
Principaux clients
Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
INEOS Chemicals Grangemouth Limited
Pentland Ferries
RJ McLeod
Assured Healthcare Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Provided immediate support to RJ McLeod in relation to a joint Police Scotland and HSE investigation following the death of a ten-year-old boy who fell down a manhole at one of their sites.
- Acted for Dalhousie Estates in a fatal accident inquiry into the death of a teenager exposed to carbon monoxide in a cottage sublet for holiday rentals.
- Responded to an incident involving the Pentalina ship, which suffered an engine fire and subsequent grounding with sixty passengers on board.
BTO Solicitors LLP
The ‘team of highly experienced regulatory lawyers’ at BTO Solicitors LLP advise clients on the full spectrum of health and safety matters. Vikki Watt helms the practice from Glasgow, specialising in defending health and safety prosecutions for both insurers and non-insurers. Lindsay MacNeill, promoted to partner in December 2023, focuses on representing medical professionals and companies during Fatal Accident Inquiries. Another key member to note is senior associate Amy Anderson, who is adept at advising clients right after incidents occur and throughout subsequent investigations.
Responsables de la pratique:
Vikki Watt
Autres avocats clés:
Lindsay MacNeill; Amy Anderson; Neil MacDonald; Jaimie McGready
Les références
‘A very friendly yet professional team that creates a safe environment.’
‘They take time to get to know you and understand the situation you have come to them with. ’
‘They are a team of highly experienced regulatory lawyers who are skilled in dealing with corporate clients specialising in Health and Safety. They work together as a team for the benefit of their clients. They have an in-depth knowledge of the subject and the industry, and their legal analysis of complex cases is highly impressive.’
Principaux clients
NG Bailey Ltd
Glasgow City Council
Fabricon Ltd
Principaux dossiers
- Acting for a multi-national facilities management company, avoiding the service of any enforcement notices and securing a reduced plea following the death of an employee.
- Acting for a local authority in a fatality involving a child at a construction site.
- Acting for a Deputy Governor of HMP Prison Service in a high-profile FAI following the death of a transgender prisoner who died within the prison.
Pinsent Masons LLP
Pinsent Masons LLP is regularly instructed to handle serious incidents and offers expertise to clients in high-risk industries such as construction, manufacturing, and energy. Managing Partner Laura Cameron is highly regarded in the health and safety space and has a strong track record of representing household names in regulatory investigations. Bruce Craig, based in Aberdeen, focuses on the offshore energy and shipping sectors, providing advice to offshore drilling contractors, marine insurers, and ship owners. Katherine Metcalfe is reputed for her expertise in fire and building safety and is active in the infrastructure, energy, and real estate sectors.
Autres avocats clés:
Laura Cameron; Bruce Craig; Katherine Metcalfe; Willie Park; Natalie Walker; Charlotte O’Kane
Principaux clients
Shell UK
Balfour Beatty Group
BAM Nuttall Limited
Peel Ports
Galliford Try
University of Edinburgh
Transocean
Valaris
Diamond Offshore Drilling
Celtic Plc
MacFarlan Smith
City of Edinburgh Council
British Marine
TT Club
Skuld
Petrofac Facilities Management
Principaux dossiers
- Acted for the owners of fishing vessel Sunbeam following the death of a crewmember in an accident onboard.
Burness Paull LLP
Burness Paull LLP, noted for its ‘excellent technical knowledge’, focuses on the energy, construction, and healthcare sectors, offering clients crisis response advice. Led by Lynne Gray from the Aberdeen office, the team supports corporate clients undergoing investigations or prosecutions by Police Scotland, the Health and Safety Executive, and the Offshore Major Accident Regulator. Additionally, Lynne Moss plays a key role in representing clients during health and safety prosecutions, personal injury actions, and Fatal Accident Inquiries.
Responsables de la pratique:
Lynne Gray
Autres avocats clés:
Lynne Moss
Les références
‘Immediate fast response to incidents, very good knowledge of the situation, and always someone available to assist.’
‘While dealing with a difficult situation, they managed to put all our employees at ease and offered considered advice. They took the time to explain everything in layman’s terms so it was easy to understand various legal issues.’
‘With excellent technical knowledge, they are able to deliver their advice clearly and concisely but with commercial acumen that really cuts through the issues.’
Principaux clients
Repsol Resources
TotalEnergies
Apache North Sea
Mercury Engineering
VSA
Sunderland Marine
Arnold Clark
Principaux dossiers
- Represented Repsol Resources UK in defence of a criminal prosecution for health and safety failings on an offshore installation.
- Advised Hebridean Island Cruises and its P&I Club following a maritime accident on the River Clyde.
- Advised an offshore energy company in relation to a breach of flaring consent that is being investigated by the North Sea Transition Authority.
Clyde & Co
Providing a ‘wealth of knowledge and understanding’, Clyde & Co has extensive experience in conducting advocacy in Fatal Accident Inquiries, regularly assisting clients under investigation by bodies such as the Health and Safety Executive, Maritime and Coastguard Agency, and the police. Practice head Mark Donaldson focuses on cases involving fatalities or serious injuries in the workplace, including matters of culpable homicide and corporate homicide. Ann Bonomy specialises in regulatory crime, defending companies and individuals prosecuted under health and safety and road traffic legislation, while senior associate Kimberley Mitchell offers support from the immediate aftermath of an incident to representation in Fatal Accident Inquiries, enforcement notice appeals, and criminal prosecutions.
Responsables de la pratique:
Mark Donaldson
Autres avocats clés:
Ann Bonomy; Kimberley Mitchell
Les références
‘The team provide a wealth of knowledge and understanding, which allows them to provide accurate and appropriate advice and legal representation. The professionalism is commendable.’
‘Ann Bonomy shares her experience and knowledge with all. Ann is highly respected by clients, counsel, colleagues and experts from a range of disciplines.’
‘Owing to their experience, they are able to provide good, practical advice to their clients from the outset, quickly identifying and getting to grips with, the pertinent aspects of the case.’
Principaux clients
XDP Limited
A & R Services
AIG
Allianz
Andrew Roger – Cameron House
Anywind Energias Renováveis, Lda
Chubb
Co-operative Group Limited
Core Cut Limited
Edinburgh Trams
Edmundson Electrical
G & A Leask
Global Energy Nigg Limited
Hall & Tawse
Kairdson Tyres
Leiths Scotland
O’Mac Construction
Orkney Islands Council
QBE
Travelers
WN Lindsay
Zurich
Principaux dossiers
Anderson Strathern
Anderson Strathern has a notable track record of representing the Health and Safety Executive in enforcement notice appeals and handling Fatal Accident Inquiries for government bodies including the Scottish Police Service and the Marine Accident Investigation Branch. The unit is led by Sarah Phillips, who is ‘hugely experienced in both litigation and fatal accident inquiries’. Laura McCabe left the firm in February 2024.
Responsables de la pratique:
Sarah Phillips
Autres avocats clés:
Mitchel Bell
Les références
‘The team is commercially aware and pragmatic in its approach, with a good understanding of the risks to us as a client.’
‘The Health and Safety team advised through a difficult period and the advice was always prudent, pragmatic, and sensible.’
‘Anderson Strathern has a long-established and well-deserved reputation in the area of health and safety. While the service it provides could fairly be described as comprehensive, the firm has unrivalled experience in providing legal representation at Fatal Accident Inquiries.’
Principaux dossiers
- Conducted numerous enforcement notice appeals on behalf of the HSE.
- Conducted numerous FAIs on behalf of the SPS.
CMS
CMS remains active in high-risk industries, including the oil and gas and energy sectors, focusing on health and safety prosecutions, accident inquiries, and corporate homicide and manslaughter investigations. Lukas Rootman, based in Sheffield, leads the firm’s UK health and safety team, while Rosalind Morgan oversees the Scottish practice from Aberdeen. Morgan assists clients through investigations conducted by the police and HSE and represents them at Fatal Accident Inquiries and Coroner’s Inquests.
Responsables de la pratique:
Rosalind Morgan; Lukas Rootman
Principaux dossiers
DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP
Renowned for its experience in advising insurers, DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP is active across a wide-range of industries, including construction, transport, and healthcare. Karen Railton helms the practice, representing clients in criminal courts and supporting them through all phases of regulatory investigations conducted by the Police, HSE, and SEPA. Additionally, Zoe McDonnell offers expertise to companies, third-sector organisations, and individuals dealing with regulatory interventions and Fatal Accident Inquiries.
Responsables de la pratique:
Karen Railton
Autres avocats clés:
Zoe McDonnell; Alastair Irvine
Les références
‘Karen Railton is simply outstanding. She has excellent judgment, is commercially aware and communicates superbly with clients.’
‘The team at DAC Beachcroft are individually strong and work together to provide a great service to clients. A strength of this team is the interaction with clients and the trust built up between the client and the team members.’
‘The individual members of the team are all capable and experienced in the field. They work extremely well together to provide a comprehensive service to clients.’
Principaux clients
AXA
AXA Corporate Solutions
AXA XL
AIG
Admiral
Zurich
Zurich Municipal
Aviva
QBE
Allianz
Lifeways Group
NFU Mutual
Liberty Global
HDI Global
Tesco Underwriting
Police Scotland
Scottish Police Authority
HC-One Limited
Quarriers
Scottish Water
West Fraser Europe Limited
Robertson Construction Group
Springfield Group plc
Glasgow City Council
Covea Insurance
Tesco Stores Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Acted for a national care home operator in relation to COVID-19 fatalities at various care home services and two independent fatal health and safety incidents.
- Created a bespoke Behavioural Safety Training package for every employee of a national public body.
rradar
rradar is particularly experienced in defending against health and safety prosecutions, regularly supporting clients undergoing investigations by the HSE, Care Inspectorate, and local authority Environmental Health Officers. Leading the business crime and regulatory law department is Alastair Gray, who is recognised as an ‘exceptionally diligent and competent solicitor’.
Responsables de la pratique:
Alastair Gray
Les références
‘Alastair Gray is an exceptionally diligent and competent solicitor who can be relied upon to produce an excellent brief for counsel, and with whom it is a privilege to work.’
‘rradar absolutely know what they are doing and the people within the team are extremely knowledgeable.’
‘As Counsel instructed by the firm, I can vouch for the expertise of the members of the firm in the investigation, preparation and presentation of defences to Health and Safety prosecutions in both fatal and non-fatal cases. They have embraced and developed technology to complement the considerable skills already to the fore among their employees.’
Principaux clients
Linbrooke Services Ltd
Ark Housing Association Ltd
Keane Premier Group Ltd
Thistle Healthcare Ltd
Oakminster Healthcare Ltd
Principaux dossiers
- Advised and represented Linbrooke Services Ltd in a HSE investigation following the death at work of an employee in 2018, which culminated in a 3-week jury trial in March 2023.
- Advised and represented Ark Housing Association Ltd in prosecution following the death of a service user in 2019.
- Represented the Central Scotland Care Homes group, which has been granted core participant status in the Scottish Covid-19 Inquiry.
Shepherd and Wedderburn
The ‘very knowledgeable and always very responsive’ team at Shepherd and Wedderburn provides health and safety advice across multiple areas, including the oil and gas, construction, transport, and hospitality sectors. Led by Kevin Clancy, the department handles employee injuries, chemical incidents, and fatal accidents, supporting clients through all phases of legal response including investigations, interviews, and prosecutions.
Responsables de la pratique:
Kevin Clancy
Les références
‘The team is very knowledgeable, always very responsive, and works extremely hard on our behalf. ’
‘Kevin Clancy understands our business and has a high level of experience in this area. He has a very calm manner, is very attentive and gives clear, succinct advice.’
‘The team at S&W are accessible and responsive, and provides information in a way that is sympathetic to the unique circumstances of our business, and in language that is easy to follow and understand. They are open to exploring options and explaining risks.’