Brodies LLP has a ‘leading Scottish market presence and knowledge’, often receiving instructions from the foremost publicly-owned companies and public authorities in the transport space. Rail and maritime mandates continue to be a key component of the team’s work, overseeing commercial agreements, procurements, and IT and software issues and complex, highly sensitive claims. ‘Technically excellent‘ team head Duncan MacLean is a ‘very experienced shipping lawyer who knows the market and industry very well’, specialising in investigatory work and port developments. Co-head Karen Hamilton is a go-to name for road mandates, acting for local authorities, developers and landowners, while co-lead Robert Ross specialises in the rail sector and is equally equipped at handling corporate, commercial and IT projects. Malcolm Gunnyeon has notable expertise in substantial contractual and delictual claims regarding rail accidents. Victoria Anderson carries out investigatory, regulatory and criminal inquiries for clients across the shipping, transport and construction spaces, while Fehmida Hanif excels in contentious work. Roger Cotton and Jackie McGuire retired in December 2023.
Transport in Scotland
Brodies LLP
Responsables de la pratique:
Duncan MacLean; Karen Hamilton; Robert Ross
Autres avocats clés:
Malcolm Gunnyeon; Victoria Anderson; Fehmida Hanif
Les références
‘Our work with Brodies on transport matters is with Duncan MacLean. Duncan is an outstanding adviser: knowledgeable, pragmatic and understands the best way to deliver the desired result whilst looking after the present and also the future of our business. He is clearly very well respected by the many officials and authorities he engages with. A brilliant guy to work with.’
‘Leading Scottish market presence and knowledge.’
‘Robert Ross is our main contact at Brodies. He is easy to deal with, organised and commercially astute. He has done an excellent job of driving along projects and working as part of the team. His in-house background means that he gets what a business and its legal advisers need in terms of legal service.’
Principaux clients
Aberdeen City Council
Agility Logistics
Albatrans
Argyll and Bute Council
Associated British Ports
AXA XL
Bank of Scotland
Beazley
BP Shipping Ltd
Borr Drilling
Caledonian Sleeper
CalMac Ferries
City of Edinburgh Council
Clarkson Port Services
Clyde Marine Services
Clyde Marine Recruitment
Clydesdale Bank
DB Cargo
Edinburgh City Council
Falkirk Council
International Group P&I Clubs
Jacobs UK Ltd
Lerwick Port Authority
Leyland Trucks Limited
Lothian Buses
Maersk Drilling
Midlothian Council
MS Amlin
Montrose Port Authority
Network Rail
North Ayrshire Council
Northern Lighthouse Board
NMU Speciality Insurance
Orkney Islands Council
Perth and Kinross Council
Petroineos
Port of Ardersier Ltd
Royal Bank of Scotland
Royal Yacht Britannia
RSA Insurance
Scottish Rail Holdings
ScotRail
Seaway Heavy Lift
Serco Northlink Ferries
Stirling Council
Stornoway Port Authority
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport
Subsea 7 Ltd
Sunderland Marine
Svitzer Marine Ltd
Swire Oilfield Do Brasil Limitada
TT Club
Viking Cruises
XPO Logistics
Principaux dossiers
- Advising on core operational services contracts for ScotRail Trains Limited.
- Instructed on the Cross Tay Link Road, which will include a new road bridge over the Highland mainline railway and one of Scotland’s largest rivers.
- Instructed by RSA Insurance and Dales Marine Services in a high-profile major incident when a ship capsized in Leith harbour due to high winds.
CMS
CMS is one of the pre-eminent transport practices in the market, providing a full-service offering and acting on premium mandates across the road, rail, marine and aviation sectors. The firm was appointed to the Network Rail Scotland Panel in April 2024 and recruited seasoned rail expert Barry Edgar from Dentons, who arrived in September 2023. Eleanor Lane leads the practice and spearheads the firm’s large-scale public transport projects, including the A9 dualling programme and the Glasgow Subway Modernisation Project. Mark McMurray is a road and traffic regulation specialist, while Christine Worthington‘s far reaching practice encompasses instructions pertaining to investment, procurement and commercial issues. Wendy Nicolson is a key port of call for public authorities for procurement and competition instructions, and Christopher Dickson focuses on construction mandates. Keith Campbell is present on a range of projects, chiefly acting for developers in major road ventures.
Responsables de la pratique:
Eleanor Lane
Autres avocats clés:
Mark McMurray; Christine Worthington; Wendy Nicolson; Christopher Dickson; Keith Campbell; Barry Edgar
Les références
‘Over the past few years, this practice has undertaken a number of major transport projects. This experience has given members of the team a familiarity with transport law that enables them to deal with client needs in this field with considerable confidence.’
Principaux clients
Transport Scotland/Scottish Government
The City of Edinburgh Council
Commissioner for Northern Lighthouses acting through the Northern Lighthouse Board
Dragados UK Limited
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport
Stirling Council
LS Buchanan Limited
Edinburgh Tram Limited
Renfrewshire Council
Highlands & Islands Airports Limited
East Renfrewshire Council
Nuveen Real Estate
Hargreaves Land
Equinor
BP
NEO
Energy EnQuest
Principaux dossiers
- Advising Transport Scotland/Scottish Ministers on the legal aspects of the £3bn dualling programme of the A9 between Perth & Inverness.
- Advising Northern Lighthouse Board on the contracts for a new-build vessel from Astilleros Gondan S.A. via a regulated public procurement, with funding provided by the Department for Transport.
- Advising Serco Caledonian Sleeper on the unwinding of its rail fleet finance contracts at the point when the sleeper service between London and Scotland was taken in-house by the Scottish Ministers.
Addleshaw Goddard
Handling a steady stream of multi-jurisdictional deals for a mix of leading industry players, Addleshaw Goddard has a transport practice that encompasses road, rail, airport, port and shipping matters, with demonstrable evidence of premium work across procurement, M&A, financing and commercial issues. Ed Watt helms the shipping offering, regularly overseeing the full gamut of non-contentious matters including commercial, employment, property and environmental work, as well as M&A. Suzanne Moir heads up infrastructure and projects group and has worked with key client ScotRail Trains Limited on its rolling stock procurement programme, while Sarah Baillie is reputed for her planning and infrastructure expertise. Carrie Armstrong and Ian Le Pelley split the ports and terminals work, with the latter handling domestic mandates and the former excelling in international instructions. Sophie Black is a key adviser for aviation clients, and Chloe Oakshett and Daniel McKinney are also key names to note.
Responsables de la pratique:
Ed Watt; Suzanne Moir; Sarah Baillie; Carrie Armstrong; Ian Le Pelley; Sophie Black
Autres avocats clés:
Chloe Oakshett; Daniel McKinney
Principaux clients
Aberdeen City Council
Asda Stores Limited
Briggs Marine Contractors Limited
British-American Tobacco
Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited
Caspian Marine Services
Clackmannanshire Council
Clydesdale Bank Plc
Dp World
Edinburgh Airport
Forth Ports Limited
Highlands And Islands Airports Limited
Ineos Fps Limited
Scotrail Trains Limited
Strawson Holdings Limited
Westcon Yards As
Principaux dossiers
- Advising Red Sea Gateway Terminal International on the successful negotiation of a 22-year concession agreement to equip, operate and maintain the Patenga Container Terminal in Bangladesh – the first privatised port terminal in Bangladesh.
- Advising ScotRail in relation to its rolling stock procurement programme for the replacement/decarbonisation of its existing train fleets, with the initial procurement having an estimated value of circa £700m.
- Advising CMAL on the procurement and shipbuilding contracts for four new passenger ferries, a project valued in excess of £100m.
Burness Paull LLP
Advising notable infrastructure developers, public sector bodies, and rail and marine operators, Burness Paull LLP‘s transport offering covers a variety of corporate, commercial and contentious work. The team's transport work focuses heavily on the maritime and shipping spaces, with the team advising on the design and construction of new quayside developments, contractual negotiations and agreements, health and safety incidents, and complex disputes. Group lead and skilled construction lawyer Andrew Little brings ‘tact, knowledge, ability and clarity’ to a host of port and harbour matters. Andrew Forsyth ‘combines a deep knowledge of the law with an ability to cut to a clear conclusion’, receiving a steady stream of contentious work from P&I clubs, marine insurers, and claims managers. James Forbes is recognised for his road and infrastructure work and receives instructions from both public and private sector bodies. Co-head Mark Kirke joined the team from CMS in May 2023.
Responsables de la pratique:
Andrew Little; Mark Kirke
Autres avocats clés:
Andrew Forsyth; James Forbes
Les références
‘Andrew Little – tact, knowledge, ability and clarity.’
‘Above everything else, when I think of Burness Paull, I know that they can be completely trusted. And not only can they be completely trusted, but they are truly a pleasure to work with. Their advice is always clear and concise, but always paying heed to the commercial realities that our business faces.’
‘Andrew Forsyth is a brilliant partner – he combines a deep knowledge of the law with an ability to cut to a clear conclusion. He has an obvious knowledge of the maritime industry and the challenges faced. Andrew’s style of leadership clearly flows down into his associates with their advice and approach being consistent and accurate.’
Principaux clients
Port of Cromarty Firth
Fraserburgh Harbour Commissioners
Highland Spring Limited
The Republic of Cyprus
Plug AS/Plug Shore Power Ltd
South Lanarkshire Council
Lonham and its insured Colin Lawson Transport
CalMac Ferries
Scottish Futures Trust
NHS Lothian
Scottish Enterprise
Principaux dossiers
- Acting for Port of Cromarty Firth in connection with its proposed Phase 5 Development aimed primarily at supporting the floating offshore wind industry including in connection with ScotWind.
- Advised Chivas Brothers Limited on a construction contract for the provision of a new access road, bridge and culvert, parking, lorry parking, landscaping, street lighting and fencing with associated drainage and services at the Kilmalid Whisky Bottling Facility in Dumbarton with a matter value of £14m.
- Acted for FHC in relation to a long-running dispute relating to defects, principally lack of scour protection, in the Fraserburgh North Harbour Deepening Project.
Dentons
Dentons' transport work centres on procurement, construction and real estate matters, with expertise in the rail, bus and coaches, and aviation sectors. Philip Knight joined the team from Womble Bond Dickinson (UK) LLP in October 2023 to strengthen the firm’s litigation offering; the group has recently seen an increased flow of contentious mandates. Helming the practice is Mark Macaulay who has over three decades of experience and works with a UK-wide portfolio of transport clients on procurement and commercial contracts; he often works alongside David McGowan who is another skilled procurement practitioner. Roddy Cormack‘s non-contentious offering concentrates on construction and engineering related issues. Euan Wilson left the firm to join Addleshaw Goddard in January 2024, and Barry Edgar joined CMS in September 2023.
Responsables de la pratique:
Mark Macaulay
Autres avocats clés:
Phil Knight; David McGowan; Roddy Cormack
Principaux clients
Network Rail
Department for Transport
Sateba Limited
Voestalpine
Daimler AG
Stage Coach South Western Trains Limited
Civil Aviation Authority
Principaux dossiers
- Instructed to defend Network Rail in a claim for compensation which has been lodged by the Millennium Hotel, Glasgow’s owners in the Lands Tribunal for Scotland.
Pinsent Masons LLP
Pinsent Masons LLP is especially well regarded for its experience in the maritime and shipping spaces, covering the full waterfront of contentious and non-contentious issues. The group also excels in community developments and the associated transport links, road-related operational issues, and inner city tram and rail ventures. Team lead Bruce Craig is highly regarded for his expertise in high-profile and sensitive marine health and safety incidents, while Gavin Farquhar is a key name for developers, vessel suppliers and public authorities involved in offshore wind enterprises, harbour expansions and renovations, and commercial shipping operations. Fellow co-head Stuart Barr is well equipped to act on road and rail mandates, and Gillian Frew acts on issues at the intersection of transport and infrastructure projects. Neil Hehir and Sarah Munro are recommended for their respective oil and gas and employment law expertise.
Responsables de la pratique:
Bruce Craig; Gavin Farquhar
Autres avocats clés:
Stuart Barr; Gillian Frew; Neil Hehir; Sarah Munro
Les références
‘Bruce Craig’s Team in the Aberdeen Office is first class in offshore, shipping and fishing work; and in other transport sectors. A real breadth and depth of knowledge in maritime work sets this team apart.’
‘Bruce Craig is a start performer. First class in every way.’
‘The level of knowledge and technology used to keep it updated sets Pinsent Masons apart from most others.’
Principaux clients
Port of Aberdeen
Winchburgh Developments Limited
Byron Holdings Limited (Falkland Islands)
Southern Cross Limited (Falkland Islands)
Calmac Ferries Limited
Vroon Offshore
Valaris
North Star Shipping
Well-Safe Solutions
Transocean
TechnipFMC
Borealis Maritime
Aberdeen Roads Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Acted for Port of Aberdeen on several phases of the construction of the new South Harbour.
- Advised Byron Holdings on the sale of Pharos Marine Limited.
- Acted for Sunbeam Fishing Limited following the death of a crew member in a tank aboard the vessel.
Harper Macleod LLP
Harper Macleod LLP is well positioned in the market to advise on maritime and shipping mandates, with a particular focus on port and harbour developments, financings and investments. The firm’s cross-disciplinary team attracts instructions from a host of government and local authorities, financial institutions, underwriters, and industry players. Tony Cameron helms the practice and has a wide corporate and commercial remit that encompasses the entire marine sector. Co-head Chris Kerr is largely focused on corporate matters and has recently advised on port investments and shipping and logistics acquisitions. James McMorrow specialises in subsidy control and procurement issues, whereas Ricardo Matteo is the go-to name in the team for financing instructions, and Euan Pirie is a PFI/PPP expert.
Responsables de la pratique:
Tony Cameron; Chris Kerr
Autres avocats clés:
James McMorrow; Ricardo Matteo; Euan Pirie
Les références
‘Growing levels of experience in marine and shipping.’
‘Ricardo Matteo is the main contact – very good and helpful throughout various transactions.’
‘Willingness to learn the industry we are in.’
Principaux clients
Inverness and Cromarty Firth Green Freeport Limited
Glasgow City Council
Greenpeace UK
Ardersier Port (Scotland) Limited
Orkney Islands Council
Clydesdale Bank plc/Virgin Money PLC
Ocean Farm Services
Aquaship (UK) Limited
Dalcross Group
Seafood Shetland
Principaux dossiers
- Advising Inverness and Cromarty Green Freeport, one of two Green Freeports in Scotland, on governance and tax delivery site agreements.
- Advising Orkney Islands Council on the £200m Scapa Deep Water Quay Project.
- Acting for DFDS A/S on the acquisition of the business and assets of D R Macleod, a haulage and logistics company.