Recommended for major infrastructure projects, delivering ‘outstanding legal skills, experience and expertise’, CMS is at the forefront of the Scottish infrastructure market, acting for a variety of public bodies, multinational developers, and financial institutions. The firm has a notable volume of instructions regarding digital infrastructure and decarbonisation projects, and oversees developments in the transport, maritime, education, and healthcare space. Team lead Ailsa Ritchie is highly regarded for advising on the planning and delivery stages of multi-faceted projects. Amanda Methven is praised for her ‘depth of understanding of PFI and PPP that it is hard to match’, while Shona Frame is singled out for her ‘brilliant tailored and practical advice’. Eleanor Lane lends her transport expertise to major road, rail and maritime ventures, and Fenella Mason, who joined from Burness Paull LLP in September 2023, is highlighted for her construction knowledge. Jenny Durie handles operational PFIs, and Vini Cowden has extensive experience in energy transition and decarbonisation mandates. Kayleigh Purves and hugely experienced senior associate Fiona Scott are also key names to note.
Projects in Scotland
CMS
Responsables de la pratique:
Ailsa Ritchie
Autres avocats clés:
Amanda Methven; Eleanor Lane; Jenny Durie; Shona Frame; Fenella Mason; Vini Cowden; Kayleigh Purves; Fiona Scott
Les références
‘CMS were appointed to advise on a major infrastructure project and brought outstanding legal skills, experience and expertise to the process and assisted in delivering an outstanding outcome on a complex project. Highly recommended.’
‘Special mention to Vini Cowden who provided exceptional support to the whole Project Team and managed a complex negotiation with great skill.’
‘CMS have a broad team with a huge range of experience in PFI/PPP projects and related models. They have worked on such a wide range of challenging projects in different sectors that there is no question you can take to them that they don’t know how to answer or how to start to address.’
Principaux clients
Scottish Water
Transport Scotland
Innovate East Lothian Limited
NHS Fife
Scottish Borders Council
Serco Caledonian Sleeper Limited
NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde (NHS GG & C)
hub East Central Scotland Limited
NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde
Scottish Water
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (SPT)
Principaux dossiers
- Advised Scottish Water on its portfolio of wastewater PFI Projects which are now approaching handback.
- Advising Transport Scotland on the options for procurement in order to secure continuity of the Clyde & Hebridean ferry services.
- Advised the FM Contractor in respect of the remediation of Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Defects in an East Lothian School.
Pinsent Masons LLP
With a client roster featuring a multitude of governmental institutions, international infrastructure groups, and institutional lenders, Pinsent Masons LLP has a UK-wide projects remit that is centred on PPPs, PFIs, and MIMs. The firm acts on various PFI/PPP handbacks within the healthcare, leisure, education and waste management sectors, and adeptly handles the financial, procurement, and developmental aspects of significant early-stage projects. Group lead Stuart Barr is ‘extremely perceptive with the ability to quickly understand the relevant wider context whilst also focusing on the complex details of the issues at hand’; he is the key contact for public bodies and developers. Michael Allan works closely with clients regarding property and construction issues, and Gillian Frew‘s practice spans lender and borrower project financings across infrastructure and energy ventures. Victoria Miller provides advice to funders on operational issues arising in PFI/PPP developments, while Chris Owens‘ commercial knowledge is ‘second to none’. Graham Young is another name of note for finance advice, while James McDonald has recently focused on the student accommodation space.
Responsables de la pratique:
Stuart Barr
Autres avocats clés:
Michael Allan; Gillian Frew; Victoria Miller; Chris Owens; Graham Young; James McDonald
Les références
‘Chris Owens is willing to go the extra mile to support a client. James McDonald is hugely committed, with an invaluable bank of knowledge. He always has a solution or workaround and is excellent in all parties meetings.’
‘They have a good broad understanding of the issues and good market presence.’
‘Stuart Barr is exceptional.’
Principaux clients
Dalmore
Ministry of Justice
Scottish Power Renewables
Equitix
Bouygues
Vinci
Veolia
Assured Guaranty
Infra Red Capital Partners
Port of Aberdeen
North Lanarkshire Council
BAM FM
Edinburgh Trams Limited
Nationwide
LLoyds Banking Group
SMBC
Catchment
Balfour Beatty
Laing O’Rourke
Hub South West Scotland Limited
Robertson
Galliford Try
Winchburgh Developments Limited
ELWA Limited
Wakefield Waste Limited
Saur Services (Glasgow) Limited
Stirling Water Seafield Limited
Glen Water Limited
University of Sussex
University of Manchester
University College London
National Westminster Bank
Kier FM
Principaux dossiers
- Advising the Port of Aberdeen on the legacy issues and claims arising from its 2016 Harbour expansion project.
- Advising the Ministry of Justice in connection with its portfolio of PFI and contracted out private prisons.
- Advising the University of Sussex in relation to a 1,900 student bedroom DBFO scheme on the University’s West Slope campus, which reached Financial Close in December 2023.
Addleshaw Goddard
Addleshaw Goddard notably expanded into the Scottish infrastructure market with the recent hire of ex-Dentons trio Euan Wilson, Stewart Maciver, and Andrew Orr, a move which allows the firm to advise a host of public authorities and private sector entities. The team oversees the bidding, procurement, development and operational aspects of projects across the social infrastructure, transport, and energy transition spaces, with a growing body of work pertaining to PFI/PPP handbacks. The team is headed up by the ‘outstanding’ Suzanne Moir, who combines development and finance expertise with a strong commercial background. Sophie Black advises a range of public and private sector bodies on the operational and handback issues relating to PFIs and PPPs across various sectors. Daniel McKinney is also a key name to note.
Responsables de la pratique:
Suzanne Moir
Autres avocats clés:
Euan Wilson; Andrew Orr; Stuart Maciver; Sophie Black; Daniel McKinney
Les références
‘True strength and depth of expertise, scale. People who are generally happy in their work and with their colleagues, making for stronger and more cohesive teams.’
‘Suzanne Moir is an outstanding lawyer who really gets how to work as part of a project team. She has the rare combination of great technical skills, inter-personal skills and the ability to ask the “daft” question which is actually really insightful.’
‘Suzanne Moir was excellent.’
Principaux clients
Scotrail Trains Limited
Scottish Government
SSE plc
Renfrewshire Council
Oaklee Housing
James Hutton Institute
HCP Kings College Hospital Y
Aviva
NHS Highland
3i BIIF GP LP
Semperian
NHS24
East London Waste Authority
Scottish Futures Trust
Aberdeen City Council
Aberdeenshire Council
Highland Council
Principaux dossiers
- Acting for Oaklee Housing as part of the Amberton Housing consortium, with Macquarie and Cunningham Contracts, in their bid for the €150m Social Housing PPP Bundle 3.
- Acting for HPC Kings College with respect to a series of upgrade projects at Kings College Hospital, London, including the proposed £16m refurbishment of the Golden Jubilee wing.
- Acting for Scotrail Trains Limited on its rolling stock procurement programme under which it plans to replace 65% of its current train fleets over 10 years.
Brodies LLP
Advising numerous public and private sector clients on projects across the Scottish, English, Irish and Welsh markets, Brodies LLP is active on landmark infrastructure builds, including water and waste, social housing, freeport, school, and hospital projects. The firm advises on the entire project lifecycle and is particularly well geared to act in disputes arising from PFI/PPP handbacks. Practice head Stuart Murray is ‘excellent at cutting through complex issues’ and has strong connections to UK-wide governmental bodies, developers, and financial institutions, whereas co-head Michael Stoneham is chiefly recognised for his project finance expertise, working with leading debt providers. Sarah-Jane McArthur is a go-to name for energy transition and decarbonisation projects. Drysdale Graham retired in 2023.
Responsables de la pratique:
Stuart Murray; Michael Stoneham
Autres avocats clés:
Sarah-Jane McArthur
Les références
‘Stuart Murray is our lead contact at Brodies. He is extremely approachable and excellent at cutting through complex issues to provide timely, user-friendly legal advice.’
‘Brodies provide a comprehensive service and are able to draw in other solicitors to provide advice across areas to ensure that there is clear and full advice which meets the needs of the project. The quality of the team is at a very high level with a very strong ability to turn around work quickly and with robust legal position alongside a commercial/practical view accompanying the advice.’
‘The Projects team remain a very strong team and are always available at short notice to assist with the issues that arise through developing a project or in managing a complex contract with many aspects after the project has been put in place.’
Principaux clients
Scottish Water
Hub South East Scotland Limited
Falkirk Council
Dumfries and Galloway Council
Aberdeenshire Council
North Lanarkshire Council
Galliford Try Investments Limited
Robertson Facilities Management Limited
Mears Limited
Nord Landesbank Gironzentrale
Principaux dossiers
- Acting for Mears Limited in its 12 year, £1.8bn Estates Management tender which forms part of the North Lanarkshire Council’s vast Enterprise PPP Procurement project.
- Advising Nord LB, Bank of Ireland and European Investment Bank on the €250m Community Nursing Unit PPP Project delivered by Equitix and John Sisk & Sons (as equity investors) in partnership with the Health Service Executive in Ireland.
- Acting as sole legal adviser for Hub South East Scotland Limited.
Burness Paull LLP
With a ‘dedicated team that is highly knowledgeable in the field and responsive to challenges and tasks‘, Burness Paull LLP is frequently sought out by public and private sector bodies, overseeing marquee mandates involving education and healthcare PPP/PFIs, major digital infrastructure rollouts, and large-scale transport builds, handling the finance, procurement, development and contentious aspects. The group is led by three individuals: Gavin Paton advises on the full life cycle of projects as well as secondary market transactions; Andrew Little has an extensive construction background; and Chris Horsley has strong commercial acumen. James Forbes is another key name of note with broad construction and engineering expertise. Mark Kirke joined the firm from CMS in May 2023, while Fenella Mason left the firm to join CMS in July 2023.
Responsables de la pratique:
Gavin Paton; Chris Horsley; Andrew Little
Autres avocats clés:
James Forbes; Mark Kirke
Les références
‘Burness have a strong projects team. They are extremely organised which is a significant help in running a smooth and well organised litigation. They have a wealth of expertise in their area but, most importantly, they do not lose sight of the commercial factors which need to be taken into account in any litigation.’
‘Very strong understanding of the Scottish market context.’
‘Gavin Paton and Chris Horsley are widely respected – they draw upon significant experience and bring innovation and practical solutions to the table.’
Principaux clients
NHS Lothian
Perth & Kinross Council
Highlands and Islands Enterprise
hub West Scotland Limited
Albany Infrastructure Management
Scottish Futures Trust Limited
Scot Roads Partnership Project Limited
Scottish Enterprise
University of St Andrews
Galliford Try Construction (UK) Limited / FM
Graham Construction
Ancala Water Services
Van Oord
Highland Spring Limited
Fraserburgh Harbour Commissioners
Port of Cromarty Firth
Welsh Government
Forth Valley College
Carbon Energy Fund
Principaux dossiers
- Advising hub West Scotland Limited on a £35m phased project to develop a new state-of-the-art education and community campus in Faifley.
- Acting for Scottish Futures Trust Limited in connection with developing innovative approaches for the financing and delivery of public EV charging infrastructure across Scotland.
- Acting for Port of Cromarty Firth in connection with its proposed development aimed primarily at supporting the floating offshore wind industry including in connection with ScotWind.
Morton Fraser MacRoberts
Well versed in the finance, procurement, development, construction and contentious aspects of complex, multi-faceted projects, Morton Fraser MacRoberts receives instructions from a range of public and private clients involving a multitude of different asset types; the group is notably ‘very strong in legacy PFI covering all the main sectors including education, waste water, highways, MoD and health issues’. Helming the practice is Rod Munro, who is widely lauded for his ‘excellent technical skill set which he seamlessly combines with vast practical experience across multiple sectors’. Duncan Osler predominantly advises public bodies on a range of project finance and procurement mandates and is experienced in the transport and healthcare sectors. Jennifer McKay stands out for contentious PFI/PPP work and has recently been engaged in disputes arising out of defects, delays and performance issues regarding the completion and handback of hospital and school projects. Billy Kay joined the firm from Burness Paull LLP in February 2023, adding further finance capabilities.
Responsables de la pratique:
Rod Munro
Autres avocats clés:
Duncan Osler; Jennifer McKay; Billy Kay
Les références
‘The Projects and Construction team is one of the leading teams in Scotland in terms of extent and breadth of experience and also one of the largest.’
‘Rod Munro is the principal contact for our business. Having worked with Rod for many years he remains one of the leading practitioners in Scotland for PFI/PPP. He has an excellent technical skill set which he seamlessly combines with vast practical experience across multiple sectors. Very good to work with and well respected and liked throughout the sector.’
‘Rod Munro and his colleagues make a robust team, with a determination to get the best for their clients. Each team member has their own particular strengths which when brought together are a formidable force.’
Principaux clients
The Scottish Government
The Ministry of Defence
NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde
NHS Highland
NHS Lanarkshire
NHS Lothian
NHS Tayside
Glasgow City Council
Police Scotland
Scottish Prison Service
Transport Scotland
3ED Glasgow Limited
Clackmannanshire Schools Education Partnership Limited
Class 98 Limited
Claymore Roads Limited
The Edinburgh Schools Partnership
E4D&G Limited
The Renfrewshire Schools Partnership
Town Hospitals (Southern General) Limited
ECG Facilities Services Limited
FES FM Limited
Robertson Facilities Management Limited
ABRDN
Bank of Ireland
Dalmore
InfraRed
Lloyds Bank
Morgan Sindall Investments
M&G
Semperian
Shanks
Scottish Water
SSE plc
Principaux dossiers
- Advised 3ED Glasgow Limited, the Project Company, on the Glasgow Schools PPP Project on multiple variations for the procurement, installation and construction of new facilities at various School sites.
- Advising SSE in relation to major elements of its Pathway to 2030 programme, including the procurement and installation of 1,000km of cable, both onshore and subsea, plus the construction of major Converter stations.
- Acting for NHS Lothian on both its multiple disputes with Consort Healthcare, the PFI company for the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh PFI Project, and its defect disputes with the Project Company running the adjoining Royal Hospital for Children & Young People and DCN NPD project.
Shepherd and Wedderburn
Shepherd and Wedderburn is a key player in the Scottish infrastructure market, managing a growing number of instructions concerning the conclusion of expiring PFI/PPP projects, with a particular focus on the contentious aspects. The firm showcases an impressive portfolio of projects, spanning hospitals, student accommodation, schools, roads and railways, urban renewals, and emerging energy transition initiatives. The ‘exceptional’ Stephen Colliston heads up the team and has extensive PFI/PPP experience, acting for an array of public and private sector entities on new and operational projects. Nigel Sievwright is active across the full gamut of infrastructure design, build and financing matters and has a strong understanding of financing and procuring initiatives.
Responsables de la pratique:
Stephen Colliston
Autres avocats clés:
Nigel Sievwright
Les références
‘Effective practical advice, client friendly and collaborative in approach to challenging project delivery.’
‘Stephen Colliston is exceptional in his straightforward and practical approach to advice, and identification of effective solutions in complex projects.’
‘S&W has a good range of expertise which is made available to us as and when required. S&W provide prompt and detailed responses to our queries and are available to support with advice and assistance.’
Principaux clients
Acciona Industrial SA/Acciona Industrial UK Limited
Balfour Beatty
West Lothian Council
South Ayrshire Council
City of Edinburgh Council
Consort Healthcare (Mid-Yorkshire) Limited
Consort Healthcare (Blackburn) Limited
Ofwat
Highway Management (Scotland) Limited
Norddeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale
Principaux dossiers
- Advising Balfour Beatty Construction Limited on the West Slopes Student Accommodation Scheme.
- Advising Consort Healthcare (Blackburn) Limited on several variations and service transfers on the Royal Blackburn Hospital project.
- Advising West Lothian Council on a number of projects involving Design and Build Development Agreements in respect of the new schools under the Scottish Government hub model.
Anderson Strathern
Possessing a ‘unique level of experience in acting for clients in major construction project disputes’, Anderson Strathern handles an array of transport, social infrastructure, and energy transition projects, with particularly strong engagement with public sector bodies and complex contentious issues. Team head Martin Whiteford is noted for his regulatory and commercial acumen and has a practice that straddles renewables and infrastructure mandates. Co-head Pat Loftus is a commercial contracts specialist and works closely with a range of developers, contracts, and public sector bodies, while co-head Audrey Cameron frequently handles procurement and development issues for local authorities, as well as disputes work. Mary Frances O’Neill joined the firm from Brodies LLP in October 2023 and adds further contentious expertise.
Responsables de la pratique:
Martin Whiteford; Pat Loftus; Audrey Cameron
Autres avocats clés:
Mary Frances O’Neill
Les références
‘The practice has a unique level of experience in acting for clients in major construction project disputes.’
‘In my experience the individuals in this team are all able, and extremely hard working, lawyers.’
Principaux clients
East Lothian Council
East Renfrewshire Council
Victoria Square Woking Limited, Woking Borough Council, Moyallen Woking Limited and Woking Town Centre Management Limited
Inovyn & Ineos
Vento Ludens Limited
Axcel Hospitality Management
Buccleuch Group
Peter D Stirling Ltd and Trustees of I D Meiklam
Crown Estate Scotland
Cireco (Scotland) LLP
Aukera B.V
Eco-Projects IOM
Oak & Green
Ripple Energy
Eurowind Energy
European Energy A/S
Locogen Limited
Greenforty Development Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Advising Crown Estate Scotland on the Scotwind leasing round granting property rights for seabed in Scottish waters for up to 27GW of new commercial scale offshore wind generation.
- Providing advice and support to East Lothian Council in respect of a new train station in East Linton, East Lothian.
- Providing advice and support to East Renfrewshire Council in respect of a potential new train station at Balgray Station, Barrhead. The station is funded by the Glasgow City Region City Deal.
Dentons
Handling the financing, development and construction of a range of projects spanning the healthcare, education, digital infrastructure, and energy transition spaces, Dentons is sought out by multinational clients for UK-wide and European developments and ventures. The firm has significant ties to governmental bodies and local authorities, and also has a strong track record in contentious work. Group lead Gareth Tenner is a go-to for PFI/PPP expertise and has extensive secondary market experience. Mark Macaulay is a construction and procurement specialist and often engages with international projects, while Kirsti Olson is recognised for her disputes expertise. Stewart Maciver, Euan Wilson, and Andrew Orr departed to Addleshaw Goddard.
Responsables de la pratique:
Gareth Tenner
Autres avocats clés:
Mark Macaulay; Kirsti Olson
Principaux clients
Ministry of Justice
Semperian
Morgan Sindall Investments
3i Infrastructure
Network Rail
Department for Transport
Infrastructure Managers Limited
Dalmore Capital
Ministry of Defence
Amey
Envac UK
Department for Education
Blue/Diamond Transmission
UK Infrastructure Bank
World Bank
Ofwat
Department for Transport
XLCC Limited
Resolis
Consort Healthcare (Birmingham) Limited
Almalyk Mining
Pale Blue Dot
Ferrovial
Capita
Principaux dossiers
- Advising on the £4bn project development of the Acorn Carbon Capture & Storage project in Scotland.
- Advising on the £5.8bn east and west coast Intercity Express rolling stock PPP projects.
- Acting on the acquisition of project interests in seven Northern Irish Schools PPP projects and associated transfer of management services to Resolis Limited.
Harper Macleod LLP
Harper Macleod LLP handles a diverse stream of infrastructure-related instructions, and has recently seen an uptick in healthcare mandates, with the firm advising across all aspects of NHS projects, from new-build to operational issues. The team also frequently engages with marquee ventures, such as the Aberdeen City Vision Project and the Inverness and Cromarty Green Freeport. Group lead Euan Pirie is widely lauded as ‘extremely knowledgeable in this subject area and very connected to current industry thinking’; he has established strength in contract negotiation regarding large-scale, multifaceted developments. Catriona Kemp spearheads a number of project finance matters, while also playing a crucial part in firm’s wider PFI/PPP and secondary market instructions.
Responsables de la pratique:
Euan Pirie
Autres avocats clés:
Catriona Kemp
Les références
‘Euan Pirie has been a key contact. He is responsive to deadlines and his excellent knowledge of the construction industry has been of great benefit over the years. He makes himself available when required and provides clear & direct feedback and advice.’
‘Euan Pirie and his team go above and beyond in providing advice on complex commercial and legal matters. They have reacted quickly to moving targets and delivered within the development programme.’
‘The team advise on NHS PFI contracts. This is a very specialist area and the team has a very high level of skill and knowledge in this particular area.’
Principaux clients
Fife Council
Forth Health Limited
Glasgow City Council
Hub North Scotland Limited
Inverness and Cromarty Firth Green Freeport Limited
Lanarkshire Health Board
North Ayrshire Council
NYOP Education (Aberdeen) Limited
Orkney Islands Council
Scottish Government
University of St Andrews
Tayside Health Board
Scottish Police Authority
West Lothian Council
Principaux dossiers
- Advising Hub North Scotland Limited in relation to the ACC Vision Project in Aberdeen.
- Advising Orkney Islands Council in relation to the procurement of the Scapa Deep Water Quay Project and other proposed schemes included within the Orkney Harbours Masterplan.
- Advising NHS Lanarkshire in relation to a major project variation involving the insourcing of soft FM services at University Hospital Wishaw.