Brodies LLP has ‘strength in depth’ in its planning practice, advising housebuilders, private clients and energy corporations alike. The team has expertise with mixed-use development applications, appealing refused planning permission applications and Section 75 agreements. Department head Neil Collar ‘wrote the book on planning law’ and is particularly experienced in environmental impact assessments, contributing to his strong track record in the renewable energy sector. Elaine Farquharson-Black is known for her housebuilding expertise, while Karen Hamilton‘s broad practice encompasses local city councils and transportation companies. George Sismey-Durrant ‘is a star in the making’, while Niall McLean leads the firm’s contentious planning offering.
Planning in Scotland
Brodies LLP
Responsables de la pratique:
Neil Collar; Elaine Farquharson-Black
Autres avocats clés:
Karen Hamilton; George Sismey-Durrant; Niall McLean
Les références
‘The team has strength in depth. It is reassuring to know that there is a broad range of expertise to call upon.’
‘Karen Hamilton is an exceptional lawyer. Her knowledge and commercial awareness gives us great confidence in her advice. She always makes herself available for urgent queries and keeps us up to date regarding the progress of ongoing matters.’
‘The team is always prepared to go the extra mile to give great advice. They have an open door policy and a positive attitude that gets results.’
Principaux clients
CALA
Mowi Scotland Limited
Glasgow Airport Limited
Energiekontor
Glasgow City Council
Cooke Aquaculture
Springfield Properties
Bancon
Persimmon
Muir Homes
Energy Transition Zone Limited
CoCity Developments
Principaux dossiers
- Assisting Energiekontor with its case at an appeal hearing, responding to strenuous objections from the Ministry of Defence in relation to the proposed Little Hartfell wind farm, including complex issues about potential impact on the Eskdalemuir seismic array.
- Advised the administrators of Stewart Milne Group on a successful appeal to Scottish Ministers against the refusal of planning permission for 175 homes and negotiated the terms of the legal agreement required to release the permission.
- Instructed by North Lanarkshire Council to provide support on the promotion of a Compulsory Purchase Order to acquire land for a regeneration project to demolish 169 flats in order to redevelop 72 flats for affordable housing.
Shepherd and Wedderburn
Adopting a ‘personable yet professional’ approach, Shepherd and Wedderburn handles the full spectrum of planning matters, advising retail companies, property developers and energy companies. Colin Innes leads the practice, which has established experience in offshore wind farm development and urban regeneration projects. Innes is noted for his advocacy and has recently advised on contentious matters and public inquiries. Ewan MacLeod is particularly well known for his work in the retail sector, while Fraser Mitchell is heavily involved in residential development matters. Emma Paton left the team in May 2024, whilst Craig Whelton joined the team from Burges Salmon LLP in July 2024.
Responsables de la pratique:
Colin Innes
Autres avocats clés:
Ewan MacLeod; Fraser Mitchell; Craig Whelton
Les références
‘Personable yet professional and responsive to initial enquiries.’
‘The team has its finger on the pulse in the market I operate in.’
‘I tend to deal mostly with Fraser Mitchell, who is always willing to take a call and give an initial response on things, providing a highly rated professional and well-informed opinion on matters I’m dealing with.’
Principaux clients
Edinburgh Airport Limited
Miller Homes Limited
Wheatley Homes Glasgow Limited
Aldi Stores
Galileo Empower
Advance Construction
Drax
Nadara/Bluefloat
Taylor Wimpey
Paul Hastings (Europe) LLP
CMS
CMS is well-regarded for its assistance with renewable energy ventures, and advises local government bodies and handles real estate regeneration projects. Led by Mark McMurray and Robin Hutchison, the team excels at offering environmental advice, assisting with judicial reviews and promoting compulsory purchase orders. McMurray has experience with heritage planning and has a strong track record with flood protection schemes, while Hutchison regularly advocates in public inquiries and drafts consent orders. Kathryn Nolin has cross-border expertise, helping foreign authorities draft and develop renewable energy legislation.
Responsables de la pratique:
Robin Hutchison; Mark McMurray
Autres avocats clés:
Kathryn Nolin; Keith Campbell
Les références
‘The team has deep understanding of both planning/environmental law and complex planning processes, makes them an invaluable adviser. The team operates with impressive efficiency and consistently delivers high-quality advice, even under demanding timelines.’
‘Plaudits are due to Robin Hutchison, whose knowledge, experience and leadership has been instrumental in fostering such a high-performing, professional team. He sets the tone for excellence and has created an environment where both individual growth and team success are encouraged and celebrated.’
‘The team were excellent collaborators, respecting all project team members and creating a positive and supportive team ethos and environment, as well as knowing the appropriate places to challenge information.’
Principaux clients
Bakkafrost Scotland Limited
BP Exploration Operation Company Limited
Brockwell Energy
Copenhagen Offshore Partners
EDF Energy
EDF Renewables
ENI / Versalis UK
Equinor
Flotation Energy
Hargreaves Land
Isle of Man Government
Ithaca Energy
Red Rock Power
Renfrewshire Council
ScottishPower Renewables
SSE plc
Stirling Council
Tarmac Trading Limited
Trump International Golf
University of St Andrews
University of Glasgow
Wind 2 Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Continuing to advise SSE on all aspects of the planning and consenting of the Dogger Bank Zone.
- Advising Nuveen Real Estate on all planning, compulsory purchase and roads matters for the £1bn redevelopment of the St James Quarter.
- Advising on the Inch Cape Offshore Wind Farm, which recently reached financial close for funding in excess of £3.5bn.
Morton Fraser MacRoberts
Morton Fraser MacRoberts has a strong track record in both the public and private sectors, listing local councils, public authorities, construction companies and energy corporations as part of the planning team’s varied client base. Department lead Douglas Milne has established experience in local public inquiries, commercial development projects, and residential property planning. Kenneth Carruthers uses his real estate expertise in judicial review challenges and other contentious matters. The team is bolstered by Rory Alexander, who is noted for his advice to local councils on contested housing developments, and Cameron Greig, who has a strong track record in compulsory purchase compensation claims.
Responsables de la pratique:
Douglas Milne
Autres avocats clés:
Kenneth Carruthers; Isobell Reid; Rory Alexander; Cameron Greig
Principaux clients
City of Edinburgh Council
BAM Properties Limited
Dumfries and Galloway Council
GSS Newbridge Limited
Historic Environment Scotland
Ministry of Defence
NatureScot
Transport Scotland
West Lothian Council
Woolfords Wind Energy Limited
SSE
Thistle Wind Partners Ltd
Tesco Stores Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Advising SSE on planning and consenting aspects of its Accelerated Strategic Transmission Investment Projects.
- Advising Transport Scotland and representing its interests at public roads inquiries on significant road projects across Scotland.
- Advising BAM Properties on a compensation claim in relation to a new office development site worth an estimated £40m in Manchester.
Addleshaw Goddard
Addleshaw Goddard offers clients ‘distinct and easy to follow advice’, demonstrating particular strength in energy, infrastructure and commercial property matters. Department head Sarah Baillie is praised as ‘an expert in her field’, assisting with project consent strategy, the negotiation of planning agreements and judicial reviews. Fiona Gordon is noted for her capabilities in housebuilding and environmental matters.
Responsables de la pratique:
Sarah Baillie
Autres avocats clés:
Fiona Gordon; Sheila Mackintosh
Les références
‘The planning team at Addleshaw Goddard take the time to understand our business and they partner with us to ensure that they are providing the most suitable advice.’
‘As we are a highly regulated industry, the planning legislation is a minefield and they make sure they have covered everything and provide the most suited advice to the issue, cutting through the legislation and the regulations and providing distinct and easy to follow advice.’
‘Sarah Baillie is an expert in her field, and without her instilling herself as part of our team, we would be unable to navigate the intricacies of the planning spectrum for our regulated business.’
Principaux clients
SSEN Transmission plc
SSE Renewables
M&S Property
Scotland Gas Networks plc
Alcemi Storage Developments UK Group of Companies
INEOS
Scottish National Investment Bank
SSE Thermal
Aukera
Apatura
Noriker Power
The Farm Energy Company
Robertson Property
Redrock Power
Greenvolt Power
Dandara
Clackmannanshire Council
AEG
British Land
Murray Group
Realty
Engie
Aldi Stores Limited
H&M Group
ERG
Principaux dossiers
- Acting for Alcemi Storage Developments across the pipeline of innovative large-scale energy storage projects.
- Representing SSEN Transmission, advising on procedure, strategy, EIA and CPO to enable the construction and replacement of existing transmission assets for both onshore and offshore/subsea routes across Scotland.
- Advising Dandara on its flagship City Wharf and Granary projects in Glasgow.
Burges Salmon LLP
The planning practice at Burges Salmon LLP is heavily involved in the development of offshore wind farms, carbon capture projects and other renewable energy initiatives. The ‘extremely capable’ Patrick Munro has recently been involved in a high-profile energy public inquiry. Craig Whelton left the firm in July 2024.
Autres avocats clés:
Patrick Munro; Paula McGeady
Les références
‘Calm, sensible but driven team approach. Astute handling of complex issues.’
‘Patrick Munro is extremely capable.’
‘They have a very strong, methodical approach to infrastructure work.’
Principaux clients
Kellas Midstream Limited
H2NorthEast Limited
Loch Long Salmon Limited
Wind 2 Limited
Harbour Energy
Protium Green Solutions
Equinor New Energy Limited
Statera Energy
Principaux dossiers
- Advised Wind2 on the public inquiry for the section 36 application for Kirkton Energy Park.
- Advising Kintore Hydrogen Limited on the consenting aspects of a proposed green hydrogen production facility in Europe (at 3GW).
- Advising Loch Kemp Storage Limited on the consenting aspects of a 600MW pumped storage hydro project.
Burness Paull LLP
The planning and environment team at Burness Paull LLP maintains ‘a strong profile’ in the housebuilding, energy and public sectors. Department head Alasdair Sutherland is well regarded for his contentious planning expertise, and is also well equipped to advise on consent orders, Section 75 agreements and regulatory matters. Other key names in the team include Steven Stewart and Emma Dewar, and Emma Paton joined the firm from Shepherd and Wedderburn in May 2024.
Responsables de la pratique:
Alasdair Sutherland
Autres avocats clés:
Emma Paton; Steven Stewart; Emma Dewar; Hazel Noble
Les références
‘In my experience working with this practice, I have been particularly impressed with the speed of responses; attention to detail and quality of advice received.’
‘The sector is competitive and Burness Paull has maintained a strong profile and presence in key cases, allowing relevant experience and knowledge to be shared to support our own work.’
‘The individuals I work with have been especially diligent in their review of planning and legal casework. In one ongoing planning case in particular, the attention to detail has been first rate to ensure the case and planning submissions are competent and robust. Emma Dewar has an eye for detail that will benefit any client.’
Principaux clients
Cromarty Firth Port Authority (POCF)
Moray Offshore Windfarm (West) Limited
EDF Renewables
Lakeshore Leisure
CALA Homes
Orsted
Bancon Homes
Balfour Beatty Investments
Springfield Properties
Artisan Real Estate
Barratt Homes
EDP Renewables
Principaux dossiers
- Advising Cromarty Firth Port Authority, the statutory harbour authority for all the ports operating within Cromarty Firth, on various consenting matters in relation to the expansion of the Port of Cromarty Firth.
- Acted for the developer in negotiating and securing a £2m reduction in the education contribution payable for its mixed-use development for 256 homes and commercial space at 525 Ferry Road, Edinburgh.
- Acted for the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers Limited in a challenge of the City of Edinburgh Council’s approach to issuing notices suspending consideration of applications for short-term let licences.
Gillespie Macandrew LLP
Colin Hamilton spearheads the planning group at Gillespie Macandrew LLP, which handles the full range of energy development work. The team is well equipped to handle compulsory purchase orders, environmental impact assessments and contentious planning matters, while Hamilton is heavily involved in planning legislative reform. The ‘excellent’ Sandy Telfer assists housebuilders and public bodies, obtaining permission for large mixed-use developments.
Responsables de la pratique:
Colin Hamilton
Autres avocats clés:
Sandy Telfer; Monica Cannon
Les références
‘Sandy Telfer was excellent throughout.’
‘Sandy Telfer: diligent, calm, honest, kind, realistic and reassuring.’
Principaux clients
Seagreen Wind Energy
Viking Energy Wind Farm
SSE Renewables
Berwick Bank Wind Farm Limited
Dundee City Council
Perth & Kinross Council
Pinsent Masons LLP
Pinsent Masons LLP is noted for its capabilities in the offshore wind sector, assisting with the development of major domestic projects. Gary McGovern is a key name in the team, bringing longstanding experience in energy, infrastructure and environmental work. Gordon McCreath‘s expertise extends to transportation and water infrastructure, and he regularly drafts successful Section 36 applications for domestic and cross-border projects.
Autres avocats clés:
Gary McGovern; Gordon McCreath
Principaux clients
Offshore Wind Industry Council (OWIC)
E Power
Tarchon Energy Limited
Cronos Energy Limited
Morven Offshore Wind Ltd (bp and EnBW)
TI LirIC Limited
Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners (CIP)
Thistle Wind Partners (DEME, Qair and Aspirati)
Ossian Offshore Wind Limited (COP, Marubeni Corporation and SSE)
Buchan Offshore Wind Limited (BayWa, BW Ideol and Elicio)
Vattenfall Wind Power
Koehler Renewables
Galileo Energy
RWE Renewables
Statkraft
Glenmucklock Pumped Storage Hydro Ltd
RWE Renewables UK Onshore Wind Ltd
Affinity Water
Cronos Energy Limited
Seagreen Wind Energy Limited
Anglian Water
RWE Generation UK plc
Drax Power Limited
Zenobe
Island Green Power
Buccleuch Estates
Boralex / Infinergy Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Advising 5 major offshore wind consortia on 6 offshore wind projects leased by Crown Estate Scotland through the ScotWind offshore round, with a combined potential generating capacity in excess of 15GW.
- Offering all legal consenting advice on the Ossian offshore wind farm, a 3.6GW project off the outer Firth of Forth.
- Advising on all Scottish and Northern Irish planning, compulsory purchase, property and regulatory aspects of a 700MW interconnector.
Anderson Strathern
The ‘very experienced’ Chris Devlin heads up Anderson Strathern‘s planning practice, which advises local councils and other public sector authorities on a wide range of contentious and non-contentious matters. Devlin has experience advocating in opposition to highly publicised planning applications, and also uses his public law expertise to assist clients whose developments receive governmental pushback. Alastair McKie has moved to a consultancy position.
Responsables de la pratique:
Chris Devlin
Autres avocats clés:
Bronagh McLachlan Hunt; Alastair McKie
Les références
‘They give sound, practical and understandable advice.’
‘Chris Devlin is very experienced and knowledgeable.’
‘The AS planning team provide comprehensive, no frills advice which is exactly what we need. The pragmatism and solution orientated approach is very helpful. There renewables planning knowledge is very comprehensive.’
Principaux clients
Fife Council
Dundas Estates & Development Co Limited
Edinburgh Airport Limited
Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority
East Lothian Council
Eurowind A/S
National Trust for Scotland
Ripple
Wemyss Estates
Buccleuch Estates
E&A Partnerships
North Kyle Wind Farm Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Advising the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority on its decision making for the high-profile application for a tourism development at West Riverside.
- Acting for Dundas Estates & Development Co Limited in its planning appeal for 46 residential units in Livingston, West Lothian.
- Advising Edinburgh Airport in respect of its opposition to a nationally important planning application – International Business Gateway.
Davidson Chalmers Stewart
The ‘exceptional’ Jacqueline Cook heads up the planning practice at Davidson Chalmers Stewart, which is active across the renewables sector and also handles the planning elements of masterplan, mixed-use and residential developments. Cook is experienced across the spectrum of contentious and non-contentious planning work, acting for a variety of developers, government bodies and funders. Consultant Caroline Court also contributes, particularly regarding development-related work.
Responsables de la pratique:
Jacqueline Cook
Autres avocats clés:
Caroline Court
Les références
‘Jacqueline Cook has been exceptional whenever I have had the pleasure to work with her. ‘
‘Efficient, friendly, knowledgeable.’
Principaux clients
UPLIFT UK
Muirhall Energy Limited
Tartan Leisure Ltd
WKN GmbH
Balhousie Care Group
JW Muir Group PLC (incl Muir Homes Ltd, Hermiston Securities Ltd)
Peel NRE
Lochay Homes Ltd
Stamford Property Limited
RT Overseas Settlement
Principaux dossiers
- Advising WKN on Sallachy Wind Farm, a 9 turbine, 49.9MW onshore wind project in the Highlands with capacity to power 34,000 homes.
- Advising a London-based developer on its continuing expansion in Scotland, including on a £200m regeneration project in Edinburgh.
- Advising Tartan Leisure on a mixed-use leisure scheme which features Scotland’s first artificial, inland surfing lagoon.
Eversheds Sutherland
Eversheds Sutherland has notable experience in renewable energy developments, offering strategic advice on Section 36 applications and Environmental Impact Assessment reviews. Department chair James Gibson is an energy specialist and has recently worked on renewables-related judicial reviews. He is supported by Peter Nesbit and Jeraldine McNally.
Responsables de la pratique:
James Gibson
Autres avocats clés:
Peter Nesbit; Jeraldine McNally
Les références
‘The team has lots of experience.’
‘They are very receptive to client demands.’
‘I have been consistently impressed by the team’s proactive approach to communicating developments in energy policy case law, addressing complex matters. They demonstrate an impressive ability to move swiftly, analysing emerging developments and presenting potential strategies that are both practical and innovative. This service is fundamentally underpinned by the expertise of James Gibson.’
Principaux clients
Galileo Green Energy
OnPath Energy
Queequeg Renewables
Renewable Energy Systems
EDF Energy Renewables
Force 9 Energy
Vattenfall
Boralex (Infinergy)
Statkraft
REG Power
Harper Macleod LLP
Harper Macleod LLP offers ‘practical and useful’ advice to renewable energy clients, local councils and public entities on both contentious and non-contentious planning matters. The department is jointly led by Peter Ferguson, who leverages extensive environmental and offshore wind expertise in his practice, and Jennifer Jack, who frequently advises clients on judicial reviews, appeals and public inquiries.
Responsables de la pratique:
Peter Ferguson; Jennifer Jack
Autres avocats clés:
Calum Gee
Les références
‘What makes this practice stand out is the combination of deep subject matter expertise with a genuinely collaborative and client-centric approach. The team is not only highly knowledgeable in their field, but they also bring a practical, solution-oriented mindset that is clearly aligned with client needs and business realities.’
‘Jennifer Jack has excellent client skills. Peter Ferguson is diligent and highly competent.’
‘Peter has been a standout—always approachable and quick to grasp the nuances of a matter. He’s someone who inspires trust and confidence.’
Principaux clients
NatureScot (formerly Scottish Natural Heritage)
Octopus Energy
Fred Olsen Renewables
EnergieKontor
The Foresight Group
Primark
Forestry and Land Scotland (formerly Forestry Commission Scotland)
Cairngorms National Park Authority
Pennon Power
Greenpeace UK
The Highland Council
City of Edinburgh Council
Marine Scotland
Fife Council
Glasgow City Council
Royal Zoological Society of Scotland
Principaux dossiers
- Represented NatureScot in a public inquiry regarding a proposed golf course at Coul Links, Embo, Sutherland.
- Represented Dumfries and Galloway Council at a public inquiry regarding a proposed 432MW, 180-250m tip height, 60-turbine wind farm at Scoop Hill, located approximately 5km from Moffat, Dumfries and Galloway.
- Represented Glasgow City Council in defending judicial review challenges brought by a residents’ association, who are campaigning and litigating to try to prevent the demolition by a developer of four tower blocks currently used as social housing.
Wright, Johnston & Mackenzie LLP
The ‘knowledgeable’ Fraser Gillies leads the planning team at Wright, Johnston & Mackenzie LLP, which frequently advises on compliance matters, environmental issues, Section 75 obligations and contentious disputes. Gillies is also active in the renewables sector, notably the onshore wind space. Nicola Martin is also recommended for matters relating to the development consenting regime.
Responsables de la pratique:
Fraser Gillies
Autres avocats clés:
Nicola Martin
Les références
‘The team at WJM have quickly and efficiently provided advice upon which we can rely during time-critical periods in our project. We appreciate the collaborative approach adopted and consider WJM to be as committed to achieving success in our planning projects as we are.’
‘Fraser Gillies is knowledgeable, client-friendly and approachable.’
‘Fraser Gillies is an excellent lawyer and great with clients.’
Principaux clients
Renewable Energy Systems Limited
Coriolis Energy Limited
ESB Energy
Fred Olsen Renewables Limited
BayWa r.e. UK Limited
REG Power Management Limited
Boralex Limited (formerly Infinergy Energy)
ARISE AB
Nadara Energy Limited
E Power Limited
Principaux dossiers
- Advised on the public inquiry held in respect of Greystone Knowe Wind Farm.
- Advising on Y Bryn Wind Farm, providing advice from the pre-application stage and continuing to advise through the examination process.
- Providing advice to key clients, including Fred Olsen Renewables Ltd, Renewable Energy Systems Ltd and Coriolis in respect of many of their sites at different stages in the planning process.