Clyde & Co houses a broad practice known for its ability to handle high-profile claims, particularly group actions. The practice often represents medical professionals through medical defence organisations. Practice co-head Graeme Watson routinely represents clients before the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service and the Dental Professionals Hearing Service, while co-head Duncan Batchelor acts for a diverse client roster of medical professionals, unions, and insurers. Claire Raftery is well-known for her specialism in cosmetic procedure claims and negligent medical treatment cases. Bethany McKenzie is a key contact for indemnity providers and insurers seeking advice on dental negligence and medical product liability work. Chris Dunn stands out for his expertise in judicial reviews and ability to represent medical professionals before the Nursing & Midwifery Council and the General Medical Council.
Medical negligence: defender in Scotland
Clyde & Co
Responsables de la pratique:
Graeme Watson; Duncan Batchelor
Autres avocats clés:
Claire Raftery; Chris Dunn; Bethany McKenzie
Les références
‘Clyde & Co are the leading firm for defender medical negligence work in Scotland. They have an impressive client base and are involved in leading cases over multiple areas of medicine and law.’
‘Duncan Batchelor fights his client’s corner to the last. He has excellent strategic judgement and knows exactly how to ensure the best possible outcomes for his client.’
‘Claire Raftery has a keen understanding of the medical issues arising in cases of this nature.’
Brodies LLP
Noted by clients for its ‘wealth of experience and knowledge’, the team at Brodies LLP is well-equipped to handle the full spectrum of cases involving informed consent, secondary medical care, and failures to diagnose medical conditions. Leading the team from Glasgow, the ‘excellent’ Lynn Livesey stands out for her specialism in aesthetic treatment and cosmetic surgery negligence claims, often appearing before the Sheriff Courts and the Court of Session. In Edinburgh, Laura McMillan is recommended for her longstanding experience in representing optometrists and private cosmetic surgery providers.
Responsables de la pratique:
Lynn Livesey
Autres avocats clés:
Laura McMillan; Lara Graham
Les références
‘Both Lynn Livesey and Laura McMillan are experienced litigators who provide excellent advice and are commercially minded.’
‘This is a very good firm of solicitors with strength in depth from partners to solicitors. I have been impressed with their attention to detail and exhaustive investigation when defending complex clinical negligence actions.’
‘Laura McMillan and Lynn Livesey are both experienced solicitors who know how to properly resource and run complex clinical negligence cases. They have a practical and commercially aware approach, but they are not afraid to defend a case robustly.’
Principaux clients
Scottish Government
Principaux dossiers
- Instructed by the Scottish Government to act on its behalf in relation to the Infected Blood Inquiry.
BTO Solicitors LLP
BTO Solicitors LLP is recommended for its deep knowledge of fatal claims brought against GPs, particularly in relation to delayed diagnoses and informed consent. Practice head Jill Harris works out of the Edinburgh office and is noted for representing medical professionals before regulators, in addition to appearing before the Sheriff Courts and the Court of Session. Laura Donald utilises her longstanding experience and ‘unrivalled expertise’ to represent members of MDDUS, MPS, and MDU, and Glasgow’s Claire White is a key name for claims concerning prescription and dispensing errors, often acting for pharmacies and general practitioners.
Responsables de la pratique:
Jill Harris
Autres avocats clés:
Laura Donald; Claire White; Jennifer King
Les références
‘The team has an excellent reputation in the clinical negligence sphere and works for all the major indemnity organisations. The lawyers provide a full service for medical professionals, including both negligence claims and professional disciplinary actions.’
‘Jill Harris has excellent judgement. If I were a doctor facing a negligence claim, I would want to be represented by Jill. Jennifer King is robust and fights her clients’ corner to the last.’
‘I think Laura Donald of BTO has unrivalled expertise in the Scottish healthcare law landscape. She has been in every major case or inquiry of the past 20+ years. She also has a great team around her, many of whom have also developed very significant expertise.’
Principaux clients
The Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland
The Medical Defence Union Limited
Medical Protection Society
Principaux dossiers
- Instructed to act as advocate for the College of Paramedics in the Scottish Covid Inquiry.
- Instructed by MDDUS to represent the corporate interests of MDDUS, as well as many of its members, before the UK Infected Blood Inquiry which reported in May 2024.
- Instructed to act for a mechanical and engineering firm involved in the design of the Edinburgh and Glasgow Hospitals in the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry.
Kennedys
Kennedys is well-equipped to handle the full spectrum of negligence claims concerning delayed diagnoses and informed consent. Rory Jackson heads the practice, often acting for self-insured corporations, while Lyndsey Combe stands out for her specialism in acting for dental practices and pharmacies, in addition to handling cosmetic procedure claims. Stephanie Canda utilises her prior experience at the NHS CLO to act in cases concerning failures to refer, misdiagnoses, and negligent surgery.
Responsables de la pratique:
Rory Jackson
Autres avocats clés:
Lyndsey Combe; Stephanie Canda
Les références
‘Kennedys have, in the last few years, grown a small Scottish practice into an impressive clinical negligence team, who can compete with the long-established Scottish firms.’
‘Lyndsey Combe maintains a suitably robust approach to litigation. She isn’t afraid to push back against counsel’s advice and frequently proposes innovative solutions to difficult legal issues.’
‘Great sector knowledge and fantastic customer service.’