Commercial disputes in United States

Much Shelist, P.C.

Steven Blonder of Much Shelist, P.C. is a distinguished trial lawyer with extensive experience across a diverse range of industries, including gaming, consumer packaged goods, financial services, insurance, and real estate. He represents major clients, such as Barilla and Vitafoods, and regularly handles high-stakes cases.

Les références

‘Steve Blonder is a top-notch attorney, great judgment, diligent and responsive. One of the best in Chicago.’

Principaux clients

Accel Entertainment Inc.


Barilla America Inc.


Cinespace Film Studios


City of Chicago


Cooper Foods International


Goldwind USA


Highland Baking Company


Kingsley Management Corp.


Royal Management Corp.


Velsicol Chemical LLC


Villa Healthcare


Vita Food Products


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing Goldwind USA in a lawsuit over delaying a Panamanian solar project, with an appeal pending after a favorable summary judgment.
  • Representing Accel Entertainment in a lawsuit where a former consultant seeks $10-20m in stock options, despite never becoming a full-time employee, with Accel counterclaiming for breach of agreement.
  • Representing Kingsley Management in a nationwide antitrust case alleging price-fixing of mobile home rental rates, with a motion to dismiss pending and potential damages in the eight or nine figures.

Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP

Shayna Cook at Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP excels in high-stakes litigation, recently securing defense verdicts for GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) and Bayer Monsanto. Her strategic jury approach and trial expertise make her a highly respected figure, having led numerous high-profile and high-value trials. Cook’s notable victories include a unanimous defense verdict for Bayer Monsanto in a Missouri Roundup trial, a swift win in a Philadelphia Roundup case, and a complete defense victory for GSK in a Zantac products-liability trial in Illinois.

Les références

‘Excellent work product’ ‘Their team is extraordinary and there are too many amazing lawyers to name them all individually, but Tarek Ismail, Shayna Cook, Joe Tomaselli, Emma Ross, Brian O’Donaghue, Ken Baum, Betsy Farrington, Elizabeth Curtin, and newly added Craig Woods are the smartest, most talented, and hardest working group of people I have ever had the pleasure of working with. Their commitment to achieving the best results for their clients is unwavering, and their level of preparation stands out even among the many other excellent law firms out there.’

Principaux clients

Bayer HealthCare Pharmaceuticals Inc.; Bayer HealthCare LLC; Bayer Corp.


GlaxoSmithKline


Merck & Co., Inc.; Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp.; Schering-Plough Corp.; Schering Corp.; and MSP Singapore Co. LLC


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing Bayer in product-liability cases alleging that the Roundup herbicide caused cancer, securing unanimous defence verdicts in Missouri and Philadelphia, with more trials pending.
  • Representing GSK in Illinois products-liability cases alleging Zantac caused injuries from NDMA exposure, securing a defence victory in May 2024 and seeing a second case dismissed during jury selection in June 2024.
  • Serving as lead trial counsel for Merck in a Hatch-Waxman patent-infringement case involving Bridion, Cook secured a court ruling that rejected the defendants’ invalidity defense and upheld Merck’s patent protection until January 2026.

Massey & Gail LLP

Leonard Gail, a founding partner at Massey & Gail LLP, is a seasoned litigator with previous experience as Deputy General Counsel at Bank One. Gail currently represents major clients such as JPMorgan and Unite Here Health. Recently, Gail defended JPMorgan in a $170m embezzlement claim and handles class actions for Unite Here Health, including a case challenging administrative expenses in a multi-employer health plan.

Principaux clients

JPMorgan


Unite Here Health


Principaux dossiers


  • Defended JPMorgan Chase against lawsuits by alleged Epstein victims and the U.S. Virgin Islands under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (TVPA), achieving a favorable settlement and addressing significant legal issues. The case attracted considerable media attention.
  • Defending JPMorgan in a $170m lawsuit from entities affiliated with a former Private Bank client, alleging liability for embezzlement by the client’s former CFO. The case is currently in expert discovery.
  • Representing Unite Here Health in a putative class action against a not-for-profit multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust fund, plaintiffs allege that the trustees breached their fiduciary duty by incurring excessive administrative expenses and improperly allocating them between plan units, resulting in higher contribution rates and reduced benefits.

Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP

Tarek Ismail, a founding partner at Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP, stands as a senior leader in Chicago’s commercial disputes space, having successfully led major cases for industry giants such as 3M, GSK, and Bayer. Renowned for his expertise in case strategy, Ismail is involved in a wide range of cases, specialising in product liability litigation and antitrust class actions.

Les références

‘Excellent work product’ ‘Their team is extraordinary and there are too many amazing lawyers to name them all individually, but Tarek Ismail, Shayna Cook, Joe Tomaselli, Emma Ross, Brian O’Donaghue, Ken Baum, Betsy Farrington, Elizabeth Curtin, and newly added Craig Woods are the smartest, most talented, and hardest working group of people I have ever had the pleasure of working with.  Their commitment to achieving the best results for their clients is unwavering, and their level of preparation stands out even among the many other excellent law firms out there.’ ‘Tarek Ismail, Joe Tomaselli and Ken Baum are the best in the country at what they do. Nobody works harder than them and nobody can rival Tarek in jury trial excellence, or Joe and Ken in their excellence in developing and working with scientific witnesses. They offer tremendous value for the rates they charge, and they work with clients to deliver their excellence within an affordable budget. I simply wouldn’t trust any other firm or set of lawyers as much as them with my bet the company litigation.’

Principaux clients

Bayer HealthCare Pharmaceuticals Inc.; Bayer HealthCare LLC; Bayer Corp.


GlaxoSmithKline


Merck & Co., Inc.; Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp.; Schering-Plough Corp.; Schering Corp.; and MSP Singapore Co. LLC


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing Bayer in various Roundup product liability cases, defended Monsanto against allegations that the herbicide caused cancer, achieving a unanimous defense verdict in both Missouri and Philadelphia.
  • Representing GSK in Illinois products-liability cases, defending against allegations that Zantac exposed plaintiffs to NDMA, achieving a complete defense victory in May 2024, with a second case voluntarily dismissed during jury selection in June 2024.
  • Representing Merck in MDL antitrust actions from the 2010 Zetia Hatch-Waxman patent settlement, with plaintiffs alleging billions in overcharges, led motions to dismiss based on arbitration agreements and prepared for a jury trial that settled in April 2023, while also defending against related opt-out litigation, including a pending motion to dismiss by United HealthCare Services, Inc.

Massey & Gail LLP

Paul Berks, a distinguished partner at Massey & Gail LLP, is a leading legal strategist in high-stakes litigation. Representing major clients like Walmart, JPMorgan Chase, and BluSky Restoration, he navigates complex commercial disputes with precision. Berks' recent successes, including precedent-setting tax litigation and class action defenses, solidify his reputation as a formidable advocate. His expertise continues to shape legal landscapes, delivering impactful results for clients nationwide.

Principaux clients

Richard and Ralph Lindblom


Walmart


Walmart Puerto Rico


JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. and J.P. Morgan Securities LLC


BluSky Restoration Contractors, LLC


Principaux dossiers


  • Secured a landmark ruling against Lowe’s under the Illinois False Claims Act for failing to collect sales tax on installed appliances. The decision sets a major precedent, with ongoing damages litigation expected to yield a multi-million dollar state recovery.
  • Successfully defended Walmart Puerto Rico against a $500 million unfair competition lawsuit related to COVID-19 restrictions. Serving as lead counsel, he secured a district court victory dismissing the claims. The case is now on appeal.
  • Defended Walmart against a class action alleging improper sales tax collection on an American flag. The trial court dismissed the case, rejecting an attempt to classify routine tax collection as consumer fraud. The plaintiff has appealed, and the outcome could influence similar cases nationwide.
  • Representing JPMorgan Chase in a $170 million lawsuit related to a multi-million dollar embezzlement by a former client’s CFO. The case involves complex legal issues surrounding bank liability, fraud, and over a thousand transactions. It is currently in expert discovery.
  • Represented BluSky Restoration Contractors LLC,  in enforcing restrictive covenants against a former VP, who violated terms by joining a competitor. BluSky secured a Temporary Restraining Order and ultimately negotiated a favorable settlement, avoiding further injunctive relief.

Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP

Lynn Murray, co-chair of the antitrust practice at Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, excels in high-profile, complex litigation. Representing major clients such as Simmons Foods, DeLaval, and Zurich, Murray handles multi-million to billion-dollar cases, including defending against substantial antitrust claims and high-stakes insurance coverage disputes.

Principaux clients

Simmons Foods, Inc.


DeLaval Inc.


Allianz Reinsurance America, Inc.


Zurich North America


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing American Guarantee & Liability Insurance Company and Steadfast Insurance Company in a lawsuit filed by Purdue Pharmaceutical Company in the Southern District of New York, which seeks approximately $3.3bn in insurance coverage for its opioid settlements with individuals and public trusts.
  • Serving as lead counsel for DeLaval in a putative class action alleging contract and tort claims regarding the VMS V300 robotic milking equipment, the claimants allege that DeLaval overpromised on milking capacity, quality, and improvements to cow health, following a prior settlement related to the VMS Classic product.
  • Defending Simmons Foods in consolidated antitrust conspiracy proceedings involving putative nationwide class actions and over 85 direct action opt-out cases related to pricing and production levels in the broiler chicken industry.

Much Shelist, P.C.

Daniel Rosenberg, a seasoned litigator at Much Shelist, P.C. with previous general counsel experience, specializes in construction disputes, representing major firms like McHugh Construction. Combining trial expertise with strong capabilities in other forms of dispute resolution, Rosenberg also stands out for his focus on business strategy both before and during litigation.

Principaux clients

Clark Construction


Cresset Partners – Diversified Opportunity Fund, L.P.


Dilling Group


James McHugh Construction


RC Wegman Construction Company


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing James McHugh Construction in various litigation matters, including a dispute with subcontractor Chicago Heights Glass and its surety concerning the 78-story NEMA Chicago and a lawsuit involving Hines Development regarding the 48-story Wolf Point West project.

Taft, Stettinius & Hollister LLP

Ian Fisher at Taft, Stettinius & Hollister LLP represents clients from startups to Fortune 100 companies in complex commercial litigation, including real estate, privacy, trade secrets, and business torts. Fisher excels in defending class actions, managing multidistrict litigation, and navigating regulatory compliance. Fisher’s expertise also covers TCPA, BIPA, insurance claims, and restrictive covenants.

Thompson Coburn LLP

Robert Lang at Thompson Coburn LLP specializes in business litigation across various industries. His recent work includes representing a high-profile player in a landmark NCAA case, DuPage Graue Mill Corporation in a museum dispute, and VeroBlue Farms USA, Inc. in a major fraud case. Lang is recognized for his expertise in handling complex commercial disputes and high-stakes litigation in sports, healthcare, agriculture, and more.

Principaux clients

A Professional Basketball Player


One Stop Mailing LLC


Parthenon Capital


Triton Capital Partners


VeroBlue Farms USA, Inc.


DuPage Graue Mill Corporation


AirSculpt Technologies, Inc.


Lovie Smith


NPI Medlogic LLC


NWI Spine Institute


UPG Group/Maksteel


Principaux dossiers


  • Represented an NCAA player against his university, obtaining a restraining order that reinstated him after he was suspended due to criminal charges. Following the ruling, said player was acquitted and subsequently drafted by the NBA, establishing that playing college sports is a right due to NIL compensation.
  • Representing VeroBlue Farms USA, Inc. as the plaintiff in VeroBlue Farms USA, Inc. v. Wulf, et al. in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, alleging over $102mn in fraud by its founders, with a federal judge denying the defendants’ summary judgment and partially granting the plaintiff’s motion regarding fiduciary duty.
  • Representing DuPage Graue Mill Corporation in a dispute with the Forest Preserve District of DuPage County, leading to the dismissal of a grand jury investigation into alleged theft of museum artifacts and a subsequent investigation by the Illinois Attorney General.

Much Shelist, P.C.

Jason Rosenthal, chair of Much Shelist, P.C.'s litigation department, brings a wealth of experience, specialising in high-profile insurance coverage disputes. Known for representing corporations on the policyholder side, he expertly navigates complex cases, including multimillion-dollar Biometric Privacy Act settlements.

Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP

David Schoenfeld, a key member of the team at Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, focuses on insurance-related litigation for major clients like Medtronic and Liberty Mutual. Handling disputes involving multi-million-dollar claims, Schoenfeld manages complex insurance issues with notable expertise in high-stakes cases, such as Medtronic’s environmental liability and Zurich’s coverage for Purdue Pharma.

Principaux clients

Zurich North America


Resolute Management, Inc.


Medtronic Plc.


Liberty Mutual Insurance Company


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing American Guarantee & Liability Insurance Company and Steadfast Insurance Company in a lawsuit by Purdue Pharmaceutical Company seeking $3.3bn in insurance coverage for opioid settlements, addressing liability policy issues and various defenses.
  • Representing Medtronic in Mosaic Global Holdings Inc. et al. v. Medtronic plc et al., where a corporate successor alleges breach of contract regarding the settlement of environmental liability claims under general liability policies, asserting rights to the insurance policies as joint assets, with the plaintiffs claiming damages of at least $56m.

Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP

Laura Sexton, an emerging leader at Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP, plays a key role in high-profile cases for clients like Lafarge North America and Medtronic. Sexton excels in depositions and defending complex litigation, managing significant matters such as antitrust claims and product-liability actions and enjoying a high rate of success.

Les références

‘Excellent work product’

Principaux clients

Lafarge North America Inc.


Medtronic, Inc.; Medtronic MiniMed, Inc.


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing Lafarge North America Inc. in Home Depot v. Lafarge North America, Inc., an opt-out antitrust case alleging Sherman Act violations related to a nationwide price-fixing conspiracy in the drywall industry.
  • Defending Medtronic in U.S. products-liability litigation related to the MiniMed 600 Series Insulin Pump, a Class III FDA-approved device for diabetes management. Plaintiffs allege a defect resulting in improper insulin delivery. Overseeing case management, defending key witnesses, and leading expert discovery, including the deposition of the plaintiffs’ expert.

Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP

Matthew Sitzer at Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, focuses on insurance-related litigation for major clients like Medtronic and Liberty Mutual. Handling disputes involving multi-million-dollar claims, Schoenfeld manages complex insurance issues with notable expertise in high-stakes cases.

Principaux dossiers


  • Representing Liberty Mutual in a coverage action against Edlong regarding its duty to defend and indemnify against lawsuits alleging bodily injuries from toxic chemicals in food flavorings, with the court finding no duty for 20 lawsuits but a duty for two under specific policy exclusions before the case was voluntarily dismissed.
  • Serving as counsel for Employers Insurance of Wausau in a declaratory judgment action against Griffith Foods International, seeking to establish that no insurance coverage exists for lawsuits alleging cancer from ethylene oxide emissions, with Griffith counterclaiming for coverage and the case consolidated with related lawsuits in Cook County.

Thompson Coburn LLP

Tina Bird at Thompson Coburn LLP has extensive experience representing major clients in business, construction, and real estate. Bird advises on contract negotiations, dispute resolution, and litigation for developers, contractors, and architects, with a successful record across on major projects and multi-million dollar claims involving construction defects and zoning rights.

Smith, Gambrell & Russell, LLP

Joe McCullough IV at Smith, Gambrell & Russell, LLP is a leading figure in insurance and reinsurance litigation. He achieved a billion-dollar arbitration victory for Employers Reassurance Corporation against American United Life Insurance Company, highlighting his expertise in complex long-term care reinsurance matters. McCullough has managed numerous high-profile cases globally, addressing issues ranging from rescission claims to insurer insolvency and financial solutions.

Principaux clients

Employers Reassurance Corporation (a General Electric company)


Underwriters at Lloyd’s (various syndicates)


Principaux dossiers


  • Representing Employers Reassurance Corporation in arbitration against American United Life Insurance Company regarding trust funding for reinsurance obligations related to long-term care, securing a favorable arbitration award, with AUL’s motion to vacate now contested in federal court, involving a deal value of $1.9bn.