Clinical negligence: defendant in London

Capsticks LLP

Fielding a ‘bright, communicative’ team noted for its‘excellent commercial awarenessCapsticks LLP acts for a range of high-profile defendants. Co-chaired by Catherine Bennett  and Peter Marquand, the practice excels in litigation arising from high-value natal, cognitive and spinal injury claims. The firm is home to one of the most active specialist healthcare inquest teams, an area in which Philip Hatherall is a key name to note. Cassius Box – highlighted for his ‘experience, intelligenceshines in cognitive and spinal injury claims, while Majid Hassan is regularly seen handling maternal, psychiatric and emergency medicine disputes. Kate Cornelius advises on sensitive injury claims, including catastrophic cognitive injury in children.

Responsables de la pratique:

Catherine Bennett; Peter Marquand


Autres avocats clés:

Majid Hassan; Cassius Box; Philip Hatherall; Gerard Aston; Helen Thackwray; Charlotte Millar; Kate Cornelius; Jonathan Smith; Tamara Knight; Ed Mellor; Jennifer Harris


Les références

‘Capsticks are responsive, personable, easy to work with, attentive and give the impression that they cannot do enough for you. They are a joy to work with.’

‘Majid Hassan is brilliant. Efficient, knowledgeable, great work ethic. He is superb at what he does.’

‘Capsticks was one of the first specialist healt care firm of solicitors. It provides a breadth and depth of talent which is difficult to match.’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust


Brit Insurance


Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust


James Paget University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


London Ambulance Service NHS Trust


Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust


Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust


Croydon Health Services NHS Trust


Newline Group


Beazley Insurance


Howden Specialty Insurance


Axis Insurance


Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital NHS Trust


Western Sussex Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Ramsay Healthcare


Royal Brompton and Harefield NHS Foundation Trust


South West London and St George’s Mental Health NHS Trust


South East London CCG


Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust


Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Foundation Trust


East and North Hertfordshire NHS Trust


East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust


Epsom and St Helier University Hospitals NHS Trust


Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust


Fairfield Independent Hospital


Hertfordshire Community NHS Trust


Hertfordshire Partnership University Foundation Trust


Milton Keynes University Hospitals NHS Trust


North Middlesex Hospital NHS Trust


North West Anglia NHS Foundation Trust


Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust


Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust


Camden and Islington NHS Foundation Trust


Central London Community Healthcare NHS Trust


Chelsea and Westminster Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Croydon Health Services NHS Trust


James Paget University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


East of England Ambulance Service NHS Trust


London North West University Healthcare NHS Trust


Allied World Assurance Company (Europe)


Lockton Companies LLP


CFC underwriting


Convex Insurance


Scottvale insurance solutions


WRB underwriting


Paragon International Insurance Brokers


Principaux dossiers


  • Advised NHS Resolution and Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust in connection with the compensation for and the associated claims by the families of the victims of David Fuller who between 2010 and 2020 abused bodies in the Trust mortuary.
  • Acted for NHS Resolution and the Trust in the successful defence of a spinal injury claim at trial where tragically, the claimant’s spinal cord was severed.
  • Represented NHS Resolution and a GP in the successful defence of a claim at trial, relating to an alleged failure to diagnose an abscess following a missed IV injection and alleged failure to refer to hospital, leading to necrotising fasciitis and amputation.

Clyde & Co

Highlighted for its ‘unrivalled knowledge and experience of the sectorthe clinical negligence department at Clyde & Co fields a team with notable ‘experience and tactical judgment’ in defendant medical negligence litigation, including proceedings arising from serious brain and spinal injuries, fatal accident inquests, cosmetic and optical surgeries, among others. Claire Petts ‘provides exceptional leadership’ while handling high-value cognitive injury and obstetric claims. Sam Holden focuses on malpractice and negligence litigation involving NHS Resolution panels and private healthcare providers. Rob D. Wilson represents defendants in catastrophic cognitive injury claims, as well as ophthalmic, cosmetic, and post-natal injury disputes.

Responsables de la pratique:

Claire Petts


Autres avocats clés:

Rob Wilson; Sam Holden; Sheryl Gearing; Christina Bateman; Elizabeth Broadley


Les références

‘I would rate Clyde & Co as peerless in the work of clinical negligence defence solicitors. They are a league apart from other defence firms in that their level of knowledge, experience and tactical judgment is far ahead of their competitors in this field. ’

‘Unrivalled knowledge and experience of the sector. Strong and determined team members with a clear vision of how to achieve the best outcome for their clients without wasting time or costs on irrelevant issues.’

‘In London, Claire Petts  provides exceptional leadership. She also handles some case work with a firm hand and rigorous approach.’

Principaux clients

Ashford & St Peter’s Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


East Kent Hospitals University NHS Foundation Trust


Hillingdon Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Kent and Medway CCG


NHS Resolution


MPS


Hiscox


Royal College of Nursing


Berkshire Hathaway International Insurance Ltd


MDDUS


Premium Medical Protection


Spire Healthcare


Virgin Health


BMI Healthcare


Chubb


Zurich


RSA


X v W, H & P


Dental Protection


Medical Protection Society


Principaux dossiers


Kennedys

A key port of call for high-value, maximum severity cases, Kennedys clinical negligence practice is frequently engaged by defendants in cases arising from respiratory, cognitive, orthopaedic, spinal and natal claims, where medical causation, liability and quantum are often in dispute. Practice head Christopher Malla is a seasoned clinical negligence practitioner with a strong track record in cerebral palsy, gynaecological, pediatric, spinal and orthopaedic injury cases. Nico Fabri specialises in representing private insurers and individual healthcare providers in a broad spectrum of malpractice disputes. Ed Glasgow works closely with NHS Resolution in complex clinical negligence claims. Lauren Packer offers key support in proceedings involving amputations, birth and brain injuries.

Responsables de la pratique:

Christopher Malla


Autres avocats clés:

Nico Fabri; Ed Glasgow; Daniel Freeman; Lauren Packer


Les références

‘Personable, calm under pressure.’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


East Suffolk & North Essex NHS Foundation Trust


Mid and South Essex Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Royal Surrey County Hospital NHS Foundation Trust


Royal Berkshire Hospital NHS Foundation Trust


Medway NHS Foundation Trust


Norfolk and Norwich University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Bedfordshire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


West Hertfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust


Barts Health


The Princess Alexandra Hospital NHS Trust


North East London NHS Foundation Trust


West Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust


Royal Papworth Hospital NHS Foundation Trust


Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust


The Queen Elizabeth Hospital King’s Lynn NHS Foundation Trust


South East Coast Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust


Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust


Sussex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust


Cambridgeshire Community Services NHS Trust


Kent and Medway NHS and Social Care Partnership Trust


Norfolk Community Health and Care NHS Trust


The Orthopaedics and Spine Specialist Hospital


KIMS Hospital


Hospital of St John and St Elizabeth


King Edwards VII’s Hospital


Spire Healthcare


Nuffield Health


Ramsay Healthcare


BMI Healthcare


Hiscox


Zurich


Allied World


Department of Health & Social Care


Spectrum Community Health CIC


Medway Community Healthcare


Medical Professional Liability Company


CNA Hardy


Beazley


Ironshore


Accelerant


Incision


Chartered Society of Physiotherapy


Liberty Insurance


Wiltshire Health & Care


Tyneside Surgical Services


The Business Services Authority


Parkside Medical Centre


Anglian Community Enterprise


Omnes Group Limited


Anglia Community Eye Service


52 Alderley Road LLP


Principaux dossiers


Bevan Brittan LLP

Part of the NHS Resolution clinical negligence panel and with a growing following of private healthcare providers, Bevan Brittan LLP’s 'professional, efficient, friendly and accessible' department handles a broad spectrum of medical malpractice cases, ranging from both cognitive and spinal injuries to neurosurgical and cosmetic issues. Practice head Joanne Easterbrook acts for the NHS and independent health providers in brain injury claims, natal cases and psychiatric disputes. These are also key areas of expertise for Julie Charlton, who is skilled in group actions. Dan Morris is recommended for litigation involving neurosurgeries, cardiology, obstetrics and intensive care.

Responsables de la pratique:

Joanne Easterbrook


Autres avocats clés:

Julie Charlton; Dan Morris


Les références

‘Very strong and experienced clinical negligence team.’

‘An excellent NHS Resolution panel team with a very practical approach, sensible and with good judgment. ’

‘The clinical negligence team at Bevans is well-led and works to an extremely high standard. ’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


MedPro


The Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust


Guys & St Thomas’s NHS Foundation Trust


Allied World Assurance Company


C.N.A Hardy


St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Homerton NHS Foundation Trust


West London Health NHS Trust


The Whittington Health NHS Trust


South London & Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust


Berkshire Hathaway


Kent & Medway NHS And SocialCare Partnership NHS Trust


Principaux dossiers


DAC Beachcroft LLP

Highlighted for its 'impressive industry sector knowledge and wider context to issues affecting clients', DAC Beachcroft LLP represents both the NHS and private insurance companies in natal, medical equipment, cognitive and spinal injury, and surgical error claims, among others. Simon Perkins often acts for defendants - most notably private clinics - in surgical and cosmetic disputes, including matters involving other jurisdictions. Simon Wortley is also a key contact for the independent health sector. Rachel Roberts-Jenkins excels in group actions, while David Roberts and Nigel Montgomery possess a strong track record in representing the NHS in catastrophic injury work.

Responsables de la pratique:

Simon Perkins; Simon Wortley; Rachel Roberts-Jenkins; Nigel Montgomery; David Roberts


Les références

‘Superb NHS panel firm dealing with the full range of clinical negligence cases. Very experienced and efficient litigators.’

‘Impressive industry sector knowledge and wider context to issues affecting clients. A more personal culture investing in relationships both with other industry sector participants and clients.’

‘Great relationship management skills, openness to engage and client focus. Simon Wortley is an excellent steward and ambassador for DACB.’

Principaux clients

Circle Health Group


HCA International Ltd


Medical Defence Union


Dental Defence Union


Schoen Clinic UK


Teladoc Health UK


Elysium Healthcare Ltd


Priory


Cygnet


NHS Resolution


Florence Nightingale Hospital


Insurance Corporation of the Channel Islands


Newline Group


WR Berkley


Allied World Assurance Company


Zurich


Beazley


Royal Sun Alliance


Alliance Medical Indemnity


Renaissance Re


CFC Underwriting


Markel


Everest Re


Corvelia


CNA Hardy


Evodental


Marsh McLennan


AMMA Assurance (Belgium)


Medical Professional Liability Co. (MPLC)


Watson Tower Wilson


Intereurope AG


Aon UK


Principaux dossiers


Hill Dickinson LLP

'A go-to firm for top-end clinical negligence defence work in London and the South', Hill Dickinson LLP is a key port of call for high-value individual and group claims requiring expertise in maternal injuries, surgical errors, and neurological matters. The team is jointly led by Janet McWhinney, who holds over two decades of experience in obstetric, neurological injury and GP disputes, and Rebecca Hunt, highlighted for her ‘keen sense of judgment for the most difficult cases’, including brain injury claims. National head Andrew Craggs is highly active in sexual assault claims, and oversees relations with NHS Resolution. Rohana Abeywardana is a key contact for aesthetic and pharmaceutical-related claims, along with catastrophic brain and spinal injury cases.

Responsables de la pratique:

Andrew Craggs; Janet McWhinney; Rebecca Hunt


Les références

‘Excellent NHS panel firm in London defending some of the largest and most complex cases. A go-to firm for top-end clinical negligence defence work in London and the South.’

‘Rebecca Hunt is super clever, very efficient, has great experience and a keen sense of judgment for the most difficult cases. Great at handling Trust clients too.’

‘The team is broadly experienced with sound technical knowledge and strong in its approach to resolution of CNSGP and ELSGP claims.’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


CNA Hardy


Beazley Group


Shrewsbury & Telford Hospitals NHS Trust


Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust


Barking, Havering and Redbridge NHS Trust


Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust


Principaux dossiers


Weightmans LLP

The ‘hardworking, efficient and clear thinking’ clinical negligence practice at Weightmans LLP is well positioned to handle highly complex medical malpractice cases on behalf of the NHS. Along with large group claims, the team is proficient in disputes requiring quantum, medical causation and liability expertise, and excels in cognitive, spinal, neonatal, psychiatric and cardiac injury litigation. Department head Rachel Knealebrings common sense, insight and poise’ in the team’s most high-value claims, which typically involve neurological and obstetric issues. Paul Thomson often advises on orthopaedic, neonatal, and spinal injury cases. Also part of the core team, Isobel Michie  acts for the NHS and healthcare insurers in the full range of clinical negligence cases, and Rosalind Bird is experienced in catastrophic injury claims, with a particular focus on brain and neonatal injuries.

Responsables de la pratique:

Rachel Kneale


Autres avocats clés:

Paul Thomson; Isobel Michie; Rosalind Bird; Peter Cutler; Sonia Morgan; Samantha Johnson; Adina Bernstein


Les références

‘A firm with national coverage with a very strong presence in London. Attention to detail combined with a calm manner when dealing with challenging matters is the hallmark of this firm.’

‘Isobel Michie is the standout partner. Immensely experienced and very easy to work with.’

‘The team at Weightmans are extremely experienced, have brilliant relationships with the Trusts and NHSR and are very efficient. Always a pleasure to be instructed by solicitors at the top of their game.’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


MDDUS


United Lincolnshire Hospitals NHS Trust


Wye Valley NHS Trust


Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust


East of England Ambulance Service NHS Trust


Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust


Royal Orthopaedic Hospital NHS Trust


Principaux dossiers


Browne Jacobson LLP

Browne Jacobson LLP‘s clinical negligence practice is noted for its ‘excellent strength in depth’, representing NHS Resolution and the Medical Protection Society in highly complex matters, including the recent Supreme Court case of Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust, a group action claim which saw deputy head of the department Jonathan Fuggle act for two of the NHS defendants. National practice head Lorna Hardman typically advises on fatal or catastrophic brain and spinal injury claims, while Ian Long has over two decades of experience in cognitive injury and rehabilitation cases. Sian Brown leads the department’s maternal division, and specialises in claims involving obstetrics, maternal accidents and fatal births.

Responsables de la pratique:

Lorna Hardman


Autres avocats clés:

Ian Long; Jonathan Fuggle; Sian Brown


Les références

‘Browne Jacobson have excellent strength in depth. From top to bottom the team is full of talented people. Working with the firm is extremely easy and the solicitors are universally likeable.’

‘The team is very efficient at handling all aspects of healthcare defence including providing a range of respected experts and expert electronic case handling.’

‘The team has extensive experience handling a wide range of clinical negligence cases, including complex, high-value, and sensitive claims. They thoroughly investigate claims, gathering all relevant information and evidence, and working closely with independent medical experts to assess liability and causation.’

Principaux clients

Medical Protection Society


NHS Resolution


Circle/BMI


Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust


Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust


CNA Hardy


Locktons


University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust


Essex Partnership University NHS Trust


University Hospital of Dorset NHS Foundation Trust


Principaux dossiers


CMS

CMS‘s defendant clinical negligence and medical advisory team is noted for its ‘broad commercial approach to the defence of doctors’, and represents Medical Defence Union professionals, and insurers in various high-value malpractice disputes. The practice handles a broad range of catastrophic injury work, demonstrating strength in cognitive issues, as well as obstetric and natal claims. Lauded for her ‘excellent judgement’, practice head Yvonne Screene specialises in neurological, oncological, orthopaedic and obstetric claims, and also shines in group litigation. Anna Walsh co-heads the team in London, and is a key point of contact for London market insurers and private healthcare providers. Kate Holbrook represents GPs, dentists and private medical professionals in cognitive and birth injury claims, including those involving early detection issues.

Responsables de la pratique:

Yvonne Screene; Anna Walsh


Autres avocats clés:

Kate Holbrook


Les références

‘Quality individuals across the board, from junior solicitors to partners.’

‘Eye for detail, calmness under the pressure of litigation and knowledge of clinical negligence issues.’

‘The CMS team in London continues to provide a first/class service for the MDU which is equal to the best of the defence solicitors in clinical negligence.’

Principaux dossiers


RPC

Highlighted for its combination of ‘commercial sense and healthcare experience’, RPC’s medical and life sciences team operates in complex paediatric and obstetric cases, and advises on the full spectrum of catastrophic injury disputes, including psychiatric, cosmetic, cognitive and spinal injury claims. 'First-class lawyer and team leader' Dorothy Flower is noted for her extensive experience in fatal claims, inquests and cross-border cases. Praised for being 'able to quickly identify the key issues and see potential routes forward’, Sian Morgan is skilled in emergency health, pharmaceutical and misdiagnosis cases, in addition to catastrophic injuries.

Responsables de la pratique:

Dorothy Flower


Autres avocats clés:

Sian Morgan


Les références

‘Very strong sector knowledge. Combines commercial sense and healthcare experience. Dorothy Flower is a first class lawyer and team leader. Her team is engaged, dedicated and highly competent. ’

‘Dorothy Flower: first-class lawyer and team leader. Commands respect, brilliant with clients and brilliant tactician.’

‘Incredibly knowledgeable and pragmatic team. Look at the case from all angles.’

Principaux clients

Avenues Healthcare Ltd


Axis


Beazley


CNA Hardy


Corvelia


CRG Medical Services Ltd


Exemplar Healthcare


GTD


HCRG Care Group Limited


HfT


Hiscox


IC24


MS Amlin


MYA Clinics Ltd


QBE


Renaissance Re


Royal Hospital for Neuro-Disability


Royal Sun Alliance


Spire Healthcare plc


18 Week Support


Principaux dossiers


  • Acting for Cosmetic Surgeon / CAN Hardy &Allied World Assurance Company Europe DAC in the defense of a claim arising from rhinoplasty procedures performed in 2018 and 2019.
  • Representing an independent ambulance service provider at the inquest into the death of a young male who died following a road collision.
  • Acted for a GP practice in relation to the actions of a former GP involving the prescription of a drug to a woman which resulted in a severe allergic reaction.

DWF

Vicki Swanton and Rosie Shapiro jointly lead the healthcare and insurance department at DWF, which is well versed in a broad range of medical malpractice cases, owing to its ‘excellent knowledge of the clinical negligence sector’. Psychiatric, obstetric, surgical errors claims, and cases arising from the delayed diagnosis of terminal illnesses are all key areas of expertise for the practice. Swanton has notable experience in catastrophic injury and psychiatric claims, acting for healthcare practitioners and entities. Shapiro assists doctors, dentists and other professionals with both litigation proceedings and inquests.

Responsables de la pratique:

Vicki Swanton; Rosie Shapiro


Les références

‘The team tackles tricky issues that arise for privately insured clinicians. ’

‘A very well-regarded clinical negligence defendant team, which fits well with the firm’s other work for insurers and defendants.’

‘DWF is a top-tier defendant firm in the clinical negligence defence market in London and a strong rival to its NHS panel firm competitors.’

Principaux clients

NHS Resolution


Axis Specialty Europe SE


HCA International Limited


Medical Protection Society


CNA Hardy


Hiscox


Royal Sun Alliance


Ageas


Principaux dossiers


Keoghs LLP

The healthcare and sports team at Keoghs LLP handles a wider range of medical negligence cases, covering catastrophic injuries, surgical errors, inquests, as well as medical equipment and pharmaceutical disputes. Department head Sian Davies - noted for her ‘excellent judgment’ - has extensive experience acting for private sector healthcare providers and their insurers in medical malpractice and product liability mandates. Jamie Colman and Jason Howarth are both active in cosmetic, pharmaceutical and optical claims, with the latter especially active in sport-related medical litigation. This is also a key area of strength for Daniel Meltzer. Oonagh Webster handles cancer misdiagnosis, cosmetic and natal claims.

Responsables de la pratique:

Sian Davies


Autres avocats clés:

Jamie Colman; Jason Howarth; Daniel Meltzer; Oonagh Webster


Les références

‘A strong, well-led team, specialising in defence work for private, insured medical practitioners. The team has a good grip of the medical issues; is technologically savvy; works closely with the insured and insurers, and works to tight but workable deadlines. They have the insured’s interests very much to heart, and involve their medical clients at every step of the way.’

‘Sian Davies is an extremely proficient team leader; she is approachable, friendly, highly experienced and has excellent judgment.’

‘Very good market presence with private healthcare providers.’

Principaux clients

KIMS Hospital


Bourn Hall Clinic


Beazley Group


SiS Claims Ltd


Arch Insurance (UK) Limited


Nuffield Health


Principaux dossiers


Keystone Law

Keystone Law‘s insurance department represents healthcare professionals in a variety of clinical negligence matters, including natal, spinal and cognitive injury claims, and cases arising from neuro and cosmetic surgeries. Tracy Sell-Peters is experienced in spinal and orthopaedic surgery claims, while Jason Kallis is skilled in medical product liability and cosmetic surgery error cases. Joanne Staphnill is active in litigation involving psychiatric claims and surgical errors. Matthew Trinder, who joined from Browne Jacobson LLP in January 2024, brings a wealth of experience in representing private insurance and independent healthcare providers.

Autres avocats clés:

Tracy Sell-Peters; Jason Kallis; Joanne Staphnill; Mathew Trinder


Les références

‘Our solicitor Mathew Trinder has recently moved to Keystone law firm. Mathew has been outstanding in defending our case, he worked so hard to defend our point of view at every stage of the case at reasonable transparent fees.’

‘Availability and personal attention.’

‘Keystone’s team, led by Tracy Sell-Peters, are hands down the best in UK healthcare regulatory law.’

Principaux clients

RiverStone Management Limited


Circle Health Group


Principaux dossiers


  • Represented BMI Healthcare (now taken over by Circle Health Group) in a group action by patients who have undergone gynae treatment for prolapse with vaginal mesh.
  • Represented BMI Healthcare (now taken over by Circle Health Group) in several claims by patients who have been treated with Transvaginal Tape.