Retour United Kingdom - The Bar

Leading Silks

David Tyack KC – No5 Barristers’ Chambers ‘David's strengths are attention to detail, strong case strategy, tactical awareness, unbelievable work ethic, always available and approachable. He is an excellent barrister.’ 
Jonathan Jones KC – No5 Barristers’ Chambers ‘Jonathan is a very experienced silk who is excellent with clients. His knowledge is impressive and is easy to work with.’ 
Selena Plowden KCGuildhall Chambers ‘Selena is an exceptional silk. Her grasp of the medical issues is second to none. Her submissions are well-researched and carefully crafted, and she has the ear of the judge. She inspires confidence in her clients.’ 

Leading Juniors

Hamish Dunlop3PB ‘Hamish is an exceptional barrister with excellent attention to detail. He is extremely eloquent, and his advocacy skills are brilliant.’
Sophie HolmeGuildhall Chambers ‘Sophie helps provide strategic guidance when needed and dilutes the issues on a complex case.’ 
Mark Lomas3PB ‘Mark has a forensic eye for detail and leaves no stone unturned in pursuing cases. He is a tenacious advocate who fights hard for his clients.’ 
Vanessa McKinlayGatehouse Chambers ‘Vanessa is extremely knowledgeable and has a laser-like focus on the issues in the case. She is exceptionally good with clients.’
Kriti UpadhyayGuildhall Chambers ‘Kirti is very approachable, thorough, detail orientated and prepared.’ 
Justin ValentineSt John’s Chambers ‘Justin is a strong and astute advocate who has good levels of awareness and can judge the mood of the courtroom. He is empathetic with clients and appropriate with witnesses in examination and cross-examination.’ 
Emma Zeb – Gatehouse Chambers 'Emma is extremely thorough and understands complex medical conditions. She is approachable, always well-prepared and an excellent advocate.'
Sophie BeesleyOld Square Chambers 'Sophie is incredibly hard-working and prepares a case with meticulous attention to detail. She is confident as an advocate and has complete mastery of her brief.'
Philip Hughes - Guildhall Chambers 'Philip is an extremely capable barrister and very impressive. He has a great eye for detail and conducts himself very well.'
Lauren Karmel – St John’s Chambers ‘Lauren provides clear and well-considered advice. She is approachable and quick to respond.’
Martin LanchesterGuildhall Chambers ‘Martin is very competent and skilful at managing tricky, technical, financial dependency cases to a successful outcome.’ 
James MarwickSt John’s Chambers ‘James is very approachable and willing to fight a challenging case. He is an excellent advocate who pays great attention to detail and can get to the heart of the matter.’
Duncan McNair  -3PB 'Duncan has a forensic eye for detail, a quick turnaround of paperwork and is an excellent advocate.'
Naomi Rees – Old Square Chambers 'Naomi is a very able barrister with considerable advocacy and judicial experience. She is meticulous and detailed in analysis of evidence, drafting and preparation.'
Rachel Segal  – St John’s Chambers ‘Rachel is very pragmatic, has an eye for detail, is confident in her approach and is always approachable.’

Clinical negligence in Regional Bar

Guildhall Chambers


Guildhall Chambers is ‘a great clinical negligence set with many members providing excellent advice’. ‘Outstanding barrister’ Selena Plowden KC is ‘an accomplished silk, with a strong intellect and a robust courtroom manner’ and has notable experience in mental health and human rights cases. Sophie Holme predominantly handles cases concerning spinal surgical negligence, cancer diagnosis claims, birth-related bowel injuries, cauda equina and fatal and psychiatric negligence claims and has ‘extremely measured and highly effective advocacy’. ‘Hardworking and sensible barrister’ Martin Lanchester acted for the claimant in Tate v Somerset Partnership Trust, where a patient lost his legs, allegedly due to negligent treatment. Kriti Upadhyay is another name of note.

Les références

‘Olive Kavanagh and Caroline Evans can always be relied upon. They are friendly and responsive to queries.’

‘Olive Kavanagh and Caroline Evans are outstanding clerks. They are very quick to respond to queries and are happy to answer any additional questions.’

‘The clerks’ room is always helpful and responsive. Olive Kavanagh and Caroline Evans, in particular, will move things around to ensure their barristers can assist with cases and are entirely on top of things.’

Principaux dossiers














St John's Chambers


‘A great set’, St John’s Chambers acts for a range of claimants and defendants on all aspects of clinical negligence, including obstetrics, gynaecology, general surgery and neurology. Practice head Justin Valentine is highly skilled in mandates concerning neonatal, cauda equina and diabetes and stands out as ‘a safe pair of hands to place complex and high-value work’. Rachel Segal is well-known for ‘her excellent advocacy and a tremendous wealth of knowledge and expertise’ and regularly deals with matters related to delayed diagnoses of cancer and negligent gynaecological and ophthalmological care. The ‘very approachable and helpful’ James Marwick specialises in complex causation cases, including major spinal and birth injuries and other conditions. Lauren Karmel is another key member of the set with considerable experience in cases involving dentistry, ophthalmology and maternal injuries during childbirth and is ‘conscientious and very skilled’.

Les références

‘Clerks are brilliant and go above and beyond to help. Adam Marston and Hugh Maguire, in particular, are two clerks who stand out as exceptional and will always be available to help.’

‘The clerks are great. Adam Marston is very swift to respond and is very approachable and helpful.’

‘The clerks are good, efficient and receptive. Hugh Maguire is always helpful, responsive and reasonable.’

Principaux dossiers














3PB


3PB has ‘excellent counsel at the top with good experience’, offering expertise across the full spectrum of clinical negligence litigation. ‘Technically very astute’ Mark Lomas focuses on claimant work, especially cases regarding catastrophic injury and fatality and is well known for ‘giving clear and comprehensive advice’. Hamish Dunlop has an established clinical negligence practice, handling complex matters involving claims against hospital specialists and cases concerning the failure to identify and adequately treat the onset of such life-changing conditions and has ‘strong interpersonal and communication skills’. Duncan McNair is another key name of note, focusing exclusively on surgical negligence and is regarded for his ‘thorough and insightful paperwork’.

Les références

‘Abi Griffin is a very helpful and organized clerk.’

‘Mark Heath is always helpful and efficient.’

‘The clerking at 3PB is of a very high quality.’

Principaux dossiers














No5 Barristers' Chambers


No5 Barristers’ Chambers has ‘a wide variety of barristers’ acting on all aspects of clinical negligence, with particular expertise in high-value claims. David Tyack KC has specialist experience in serious injury claims. Jonathan Jones KC is a ‘very good advocate and an exceptional negotiator’ who represents both claimants and defendants on damage cases along with matters involving serious brain injuries.

Les références

‘Excellent clerking team led by the impressive William Theaker.’

‘William Theaker is excellent, available, quick to respond and easy to work with.’

‘The clears are excellent, all very helpful and responsive.’